Magic Friends

popsicletrees

Well-Known Member
Theory of Forms was in the Republic. Well, Allegory of the Cave was. Which is the Theory of Forms. Sparknotes Version.

There is a special section in my copy of the Republic about the Theory of Forms.

I used the allegory of the cave to compare and contrast idealists and realists in a paper for my foundations of 20th century America class.
 

WDWSwashbuckler

New Member
Theory of Forms was in the Republic. Well, Allegory of the Cave was. Which is the Theory of Forms. Sparknotes Version.

Haha, fair enough. It's really hard to differentiate in the Republic what's Socrates and what's Plato. Obviously, we have the Socrates character speaking, and some deep Socratic impact, but so much scholarship points to the "Utopia" as being fully Platonic.
 

WDWSwashbuckler

New Member
I didn't mean to sound demeaning, btw. I realize I kinda rubbed off the way, saying that I was talking about Plato and not Socrates. I just failed to explain that I'm explicitly talking about Plato's philosophy. It's hard determining whether Plato accepted the Forms so well as Socrates. It seems to me that he ended up being somewhere in the middle of the road between Socrates and Aristotle in the end.
 

popsicletrees

Well-Known Member
I didn't mean to sound demeaning, btw. I realize I kinda rubbed off the way, saying that I was talking about Plato and not Socrates. I just failed to explain that I'm explicitly talking about Plato's philosophy. It's hard determining whether Plato accepted the Forms so well as Socrates. It seems to me that he ended up being somewhere in the middle of the road between Socrates and Aristotle in the end.

Aristotle :hurl:
 

Pongo

New Member
Was that a philosophical question?
Indeed - where are any of us?

:ROFLOL:


Never heard of it.

Haha, fair enough. It's really hard to differentiate in the Republic what's Socrates and what's Plato. Obviously, we have the Socrates character speaking, and some deep Socratic impact, but so much scholarship points to the "Utopia" as being fully Platonic.

I choose to believe that Plato just used Socrates as a vessel to convey his own beliefs.
 

Uponastar

Well-Known Member
Was that a philosophical question?
Indeed - where are any of us?

caked.gif
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom