I have been here maybe 10 times. Last time was about a month ago. I would classify it as an off night. Not bad, just not up to par. Kids were happy with what they got (duck, pasta, and chicken). I the Mrs. was happy with her Filet Mignon and said the onion soup was quite good. The briased short rib, which I have had before, were just off this evening. Good, but not to the level they normaly were. Desserts were quite good. Wine was not a bad price (considering it was WDW) and the service and atmosphere is, as was said above, French - as should be expected in a Frence brassire, created by French chefs, and staffed by people from France. In most of Europe, dinner is not something to be eaten - gobble, gobble, gobble, and then bang, zoom out the door. It is about lingering, taking your time, enjoying your companions, talking, eating, and socailzing.
-dave