It's impressive that so many people fail to see the problem with some of these upcharge events lately.
The difference is many people are here just as CUSTOMERS of Disney. They are here to find out about the latest products and offerings and compare notes with others in what is good, or bad. Many use the online world to help get their Disney fix by looking at, chatting about, and simply immersing part of their day in Disney topics.
These are the folks that will say 'it doesnt impact me...' or 'why are focusing on something that just upsets you', etc etc. Because they are primarily driven by motivators as CUSTOMERS... they have less interest in topics that don't directly impact things they are looking to interact directly with.
The other group are people that are not only interested in Disney as customers... but interested in (to put it simply..) the ART OF DISNEY. As in, what made or makes Disney... Disney? What is it about XYZ that makes it work so well? Or be so different from other efforts? That means the trade of imagineering... the business philosophies of the leadership that steered their choices... how they develop concepts.. how they market.. how they address customer service.. etc. This is an interest in the development, business strategies, and 'science' of an entertainment business.. and most specifically a THEME PARK business.
Clearly how a CUSTOMER would study a topic like... the styling of a structure... would be very different than someone who is interested in the how/why/execution of that structure.
The problem in forums like these is these audiences are generally intermixed... and people frequently fail to separate their OWN focus and boundaries of interest when interacting with others. Thus we end up with the 'why do you care about that...' situation you see happening in this thread.
Many CUSTOMERS are simply saying "I think the offer stinks, not for me..." and they think its done
Others, who are interested in the strategies, design, and other elements try to discuss what this offer means and the conversation goes beyond 'would I use it?' 'does it impact my next vacation?'.
Then you have some who just don't understand the difference and why both are important and cause friction because they interject the wrong stuff in the wrong conversation.