Gomer
Well-Known Member
I think Revenge of the Sith gets lumped in with the crappiness of the prequels even though it doesn't deserve it. Revenge of the Sith is definitely a solid movie, but Attack of the Clones is awful.
I honestly think all of them have some redeeming qualities. Clones has one of my all time favorite John Williams scores. TPM is not all that bad if you just watch from the podrace scene to the end. But poor writing and a director who had no interest in the actors brought down the movies for the most part.
I do agree though. ROTS is the best of the prequels by far and is brought down by 3 or 4 really horrific scenes which stand out in peoples memory (Padme's hair bushing flirtations comes to mind). But,honestly overall I think its somewhat comparable in quality to Return of the Jedi, which sometimes gets a free pass for some of its own flaws because of its link to the first two, far superior, films.