ItlngrlBella
Well-Known Member
For a minute I was expecting the Occupy crowd to come around. Thank goodness there are no police cars around here for them to poop on.
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
Hotelier Ian Schrager working on Disney Hotels.
- Thread starter DDLand
- Start date
For a minute I was expecting the Occupy crowd to come around. Thank goodness there are no police cars around here for them to poop on.
ford91exploder
Resident Curmudgeon
See any of the DVC threads for what has been removed from the Deluxe resorts all the while cranking up the member fees.
That's why I'm surmising that this is going to be third party operated. Likely by him. He's not an architect, so much as he's an experience creater. He believes that the design is one part of a bigger picture. He has worked with some great designers, and also some great partners too.
CaptainAmerica
Well-Known Member
Yeah, I didn't think so.
Jahona
Well-Known Member
Actually I have been to flight school. Couldn't finish due to life reasons. My instructors motto was. Taking off is easy. Your going to land if you like it or not, make sure you do it right.
TRONorail12
Active Member
The article states it's based off of some of Walt's hotel sketches. For WDW, this would have been an Asian and Venetian themed resort on the Seven Seas Lagoon and a Persian resort on Bay Lake. What's even more interesting is that he already has hotels in development for Sanya (China), Bangkok (Thailand), Gurgaon (India), Abu Dhabi (United Arab Emirates) and Shanghai (China), with an existing hotel already built in Istanbul (Turkey). Sounds like he would bring a lot of experience and knowledge to the table in regards to at least the Asian and Persian themes. I still think there is potential for another Magic Kingdom resort around the 7 Seas Lagoon. The original Venetian site between TTC and Contemporary would be my first choice, but if you look at Google Earth, there is also a lot of potential between MK and the Grand Floridian.
I doubt it. He's a hotel operator that values design, not an architect.
Plus have you seen Jambo House or GFV?
ford91exploder
Resident Curmudgeon
I usually stay at 1BR or higher WDW properties - I'll just list a couple
1 - Maintenance (veneer missing from BLT fixtures and broken appliances at checkin)
2 - Themed dinnerware removed at AKL and elsewhere in favor of cheap 'institutional' dinnerware which would be appropriate at the enlisted chow hall not the Officers wardroom.
3 - replacement of themed linens with cheap white linens
4 - reduction in quality of the toiletries as well as quantity.
5 - reduction of resort restaurant hours and menu choices.
I could go on for hours here
CDavid
Well-Known Member
Only if said redo includes demolition of the ugly, out of place, abomination of architectural design Bay Lake Tower next door.
Interesting. I'm not sure if he was involved in those projects or not. Remember the Resort Area as Walt presented it during his Epcot film was not nearly as grand, or even the main focus. He wasn't even on the design committee for MK. Did he have a hand in designing them? That's the million dollar question.
ford91exploder
Resident Curmudgeon
Then you understand exactly what I mean.
I actually (I'm putting my good name at stake here) prefer Bay Lake Tower design to the Contemporary Resort proper. Call me crazy, but the smooth lines of that Hotel to me represent the modern design goals much more. No one said Contemporary had to be jagged and sharp.
CaptainAmerica
Well-Known Member
1. Maintenance isn't an amenity.
2. Plates aren't amenities and many "deluxe" style travelers would consider themed plates to be cheesy.
3. Themed linens were replaced with white linens property wide. It's a health issue. White linens can be bleached. This was a major initiative that cost a significant amount of money to deploy. It was not a cost cutting initiative.
4. The H20 toiletries are far superior to the crap they used to provide. You're crying about the quantity, seriously? They'll bring you more if you take three seconds to call the front desk.
5. Jiko, Citricos, Cali Grill, etc. are open until 10 PM. How the heck late do you eat dinner?
CDavid
Well-Known Member
There is clearly one thing which is even more inappropriate and uncalled for on the boards than class envy, and that is condescension.
While you have a legitimate point, ascribing all criticism of premium-priced offerings to "class envy' rather misses completely valid arguments about the development and interests of Walt Disney World's "bread & butter" middle-class guests.
Which also makes the hotel rooms look more like a hospital ward and far less like the themed resort it's supposed to represent. I know its the current style and all, and some people actually like it, but its one thing I can't wait to go out of style.
CaptainAmerica
Well-Known Member
A sarcastic post about "the 1%" is absolutely NOT a "completely valid argument about the development and interests of Walt Disney World's 'bread and butter' middle-class guests."
ETA: I'm absolutely not in "the 1%" but I stay in deluxe resorts. Disney's bread and butter middle class are EXACTLY the people staying in Disney's deluxe resorts.
ford91exploder
Resident Curmudgeon
You really don't get it do you?,
I'm Hilton Diamond and Marriott Platinum I KNOW what a good hotel looks like, I know what a good hotel is maintained like maintenance quality is very much an anmenity and some properties especially those in major cities are known for their spotless appearance everywhere from the doormans uniform to the grout in the washrooms.
The dinnerware in both Marriott's 'Residence Inn' and Hilton's 'Homewood Suites' are several cuts above what is at Disney which is cheap institutional dinnerware. GOOD hotels with kitchen service suites usually have dinnerware which is unique to the property and in some cases unique to the suite itself.
I liked the H20 Stuff, Even bought the larger quantity from the Disney store for use at home, But as of December at BLT (in a Grand Villa) it had been replaced with some generic 'Disney Parks' carp
The current linens are CHEAP low thread count linens, Disney may have spent a lot of money I suspect they will be spending more to replace these frequently.
Most good hotels have room service till at least midnight, And lunch hours at places like the 'Turf Club' at SSR have been axed.
Disney charges FAR more than a first class Hilton or Marriott yet their amenities fall far short of the average Hilton Garden Inn or Fairfield.
CaptainAmerica
Well-Known Member
I'm also Hilton diamond so you get no "impressed" points from me on that. I also travel quite a bit to various HGVC properties with my in-laws. I've seen nothing at Disney timeshare resorts that isn't at the very least on par with the nicest of those resorts, especially Hilton's central Florida properties.
Did you ever actually GO to lunch at Turf Club? The place was absolutely empty always. "Most good hotels" serve lunch because "most good hotels" don't have 98% of the clients out at a theme park during lunch hours.
ETA: And I was extremely bummed that they closed TC for lunch. Those buffalo chicken nachos were on point.
ford91exploder
Resident Curmudgeon
If you are Diamond WHY do you accept the constantly declining standards of Disney hotels, unless of course you only stay in Hampton Inn's (Most of which are STILL better than Disney's properties)
Actually I went to the Turf Club quite often, They used to have a decent small steak for lunch, Then it was burgers now it's just overflow seating for the Artists Palatte.
yensid67
Well-Known Member
THE ONLY PLACE I COULD EVER SEE THIS GUYS 'TASTES' WORKING IS A COM;LETE REDO OF THE CONTEMPORARY! BUT why do that while the parks are in complete disarray and need more TLC than anything on property!? You would think that if they had better updated and expanded parks then the occupancy levels would rise and justify an addition to hotels on property. Anything other than that is not justified action!
Disney can do both at once. This is not going to pull them away from something pressing.