This is all true. And the creation of 3-5 new people is important, long term. But the current management only appears to be concerned with short term, quarter by quarter ROIs.
To the other issue of eschewing return guests, I do think there's a long term problem when you forcibly break people of ingrained habits (as we've learned from the pandemic). What happens when the people who've routinely come back multiple times a year no longer do so? Yes, current attendance is up, but I think that's a byproduct of cash-heavy folks and revenge travel. What happens during the inevitable economic downturn? Do they raise rack rates at GF and Poly to over $1000/night because their new desired clientele will easily pay for it?
I do think there's a reckoning in store. When that happens is anyone's guess. The current CEO is in his early 60's and feels like a placeholder. These issues will be someone else's to deal with, ultimately.