To me the Dinoland debate makes clear a glaring problem Disney has...despite 3 attempts, they have been unable to create a story about dinosaurs that the general audience falls in love with.
The 2000 movie DINOSAUR which the ride at Animal Kingdom is loosely based on, was in my opinion one of the most beautiful motion pictures that Disney produced at the turn of the millennium, but it was not a major box office success.
THE GOOD DINOSAUR was a cute movie, but also got hit by an asteroid at the box office.
The Animal Kingdom ride DINOSAUR in my opinion, has been the best dino story that Disney has produced, even though it is just a few minutes in length.
Other studios have proved that dino stories can be popular if produced well. Jurassic Park/World is proof of that. So is Land Before Time. And while not dino centered, so is Ice Age. Disney acquiring the rights to Ice Age, could have opened up an interesting possibility to retheme Dinosaur to thay intelectual property, but I think the hype over Ice Age is pretty much over.
It seems like a glaring opportunity, as we approach a decade since Disney's last attempt to produce a story about dinosaurs that the audience will fall in love with. Personally, I think the best approach would be to produce a major motion picture that continues its story as a Disney+ series, which then can lead to a retheme of the ride at Animal Kingdom.
Sorry to keep this post going, but I have one more point to make about this...
I kind of view the current layout of Animal Kingdom as similar to EPCOT, where the lands at the front of the park to your left and right reflect on our past, present and future and have a bit of fantasy to them. Then those lands lead you to the back of the park where the attractions celebrate the way we connect with culture. I love that and feel that the 2 proposals that have been shared, especially this most recent one, would dramatically change that balance for Animal Kingdom.
The park needs more to do, as most guests view it as a half day park at best. It needs an entirely new area in addition to the love and care that everyone acknowledges Dinoland needs. Whether that is a South American land, Australian land or an Arctic land, I believe it should be added, north of Pandora, so that you can keep the same balance that the park has now.
Whatever is done, I hope it will further enhance one of my favorite theme parks ever built, so that even more people can come to appreciate Animal Kingdom as much as I do.