Does anyone else think an American Idol attractions a bad Idea?

[rictusred]

I usually go along with the attraction ideas the imagineers come up with. But when I heard that they were doing an American Idol :hammer:attraction I was really put off especially in MGM ... sorry Hollywood studios where I believe they have fallen a little short on the imagination in there attractions. plus using more of a fad show as a backdrop that will eventually fall of ala who wants to be a millionaire. When they have so much material they can use to create an attraction. I would have even prefered a National Treasure attraction over this. any way let me know what you guys think.

 

[urbanvegan]

I don't think it's a *bad* idea, but it definitely isn't long term, which is alright. For now, AI enjoys tremendous popularity. Disney doesn't build every attraction with the intention of it lasting for 25 years. I think that these "trendier" attractions like AI and the "High School Musical" shows help keep the parks current & fresh, and balance out the mainstays.

It's just not up my alley though, so I doubt I will be seeing it. I hope it is done well, though - for the sake of those who will be.

 

[Gooch]

I don't like it either and can't help but think that once the American Idol craze fades (though it might not be anytime soon) that this attraction will as well. I would have preferred to see something in its place, but hey.

I would have like an AI ride where you twist and turn while Simon hurls insults at you. Ha.

 

[yankspy]

BAD IDEA. Perhaps from a marketing standpoint it is a good idea I just do not like it. I always thought that the philosophy of WDW was to escape all reminders of everyday life. It is sort of why the property is or was so insulated from outside influences. This does not do that for me. Neither does most of DTD although I do like the Adventurer's club. However, I am sure there are valid reasons for doing so.

 

[Thiger]

Call it American Idol, I call it Karaoke.
And Karaoke is really really fun.
Although this attraction with not have booze, which helps to make the bad singers more bearable
but come now, it's going to be really awesome to get on stage and sing it up
I just hope they have like 50,000 songs to sing. It'll be horrible if there's only like 2-300 songs.


I honestly cant wait and have been wishing for a karaoke bar in PI with animatronics (picture Mickey's Karaoke Jam). That would rock.

 

[Pioneer Hall]

I don't like the idea, because I feel that American Idol is already starting to lose some of its popularity. Give it another 5 years and people will probably not even be watching it. I would have rather seen something more permanent in that location.

 

[ShookieJones]

Bad idea...

American Idol - is a completely guilty pleasure of mine.
I am a musician and I normally loath what this show promotes:
Singers who don't write their own songs - basically pop figure heads ala Britney Spears....(although over the last few years this seems to be changing and there seems to be more singer\songwriting rockers on the show)..but alas I digress -

All that being said - AI is GREAT TV - the popularity isn't going to wane anytime soon - it's been on for several seasons and formula works - it keeps breaking TV viewing records....so I can see why Disney would hop on this and try to make something of it -
BUT I don't see how they plan on setting this up and who in the world wants to sit through a Karaoke concert...
I just don't get it - then again I never understood - Karaoke.
Could you imagine if I came to you all with this idea -
"Picture this everyone - I got this idea, we can all sit around and subject ourselves to listening to each other sing out of tune" "It'll be great people will line up to get snickered at by other people" Whaddya think? Million dollar idea right??
For whatever reason people love it...:brick:

So after all that jabbering -
My opinion = horrible idea and a waste of space in park that needs more RIDES - not shows
Bottom line -
My opinion apparently doesn't mean much, and it will most likely be a huge hit for years to come!

 

[Pumbas Nakasak]

Speaking as someone with a fantastic voice I cant wait to unleash my talent at the Studios. Thats life, Killing in the name of, Mob Scene are all part of my repertoire and would go down a storm.

I mean who wants to go to a theme park and see themed attractions when they can have pub entertainment with lights and a decent sound system.

 

[Jerm]

Yes lots of people do

 

[MousDad]

Seems like the general consensus is that once AI is off the air, an AI attraction will immediately become unpopular and be closed down (a la Millionaire). But I'm not so sure.

AI has achieved historical, pop-cultural icon status at this point, IMO. I could see an attraction possibly living on for years after the show's demise. Only time will tell.

 

[ELopez]

I actually think it might be a hit. AI and all of the wanna-be shows have bajillions of people lining up to audition. SO many people think they can sing. I, of course, KNOW that I am awesome. Anyway, I think a lot of people will want to give it a shot.

And as far as watching, it's the same reason everyone likes the AI auditions - to see the really good ones, and the really outrageous ones.

So, you never know.

 

[EPCOT Explorer]

Yes....It just seems so un-Disney to me.

 

[tcwickings]

Yes ,yes ,yes.

 

[Thiger]

thats why Mickey's Karaoke Jam Party would be better.
Imagine doing karaoke (for Adults & Kids) with AA Mickey and Minnie leading the show? Even do it like MIF or TTWCrush and it would go over really well.

Or have Donald, that would rock too
hehehe

I'm ok with AI. I don't really watch the show but i love karaoke. I think it would be cute to see kids singing their fav songs.

 

[doop]

Indeed, but I'll give it a chance.

 

[wdwmomof3]

I think it will be fun, but I love AI so that may be why. You will NEVER see me on stage though.:lol:

 

[apatten22]

I just don't see the need to add another attraction like this to a park that has so many shows already. Rides are what they need to attract a varying degree of patrons.


RIDES:
Great Movie Ride
Star Tours
Backlot Tour
Tower of Terror
Rock N Rollercoaster
Toy Story Mania (coming soon)

 

[MainStreetMouse]

As long as it is better than that Drew Carey "Sounds Dangerous" thing that they are calling an attraction.

Gary

 

[sknydave]

It's a show... People act like a show needs to be around as long as a ride. I actually like to see shows be replaced after some time. I don't like watching the same show over and over again.

 

[daliseurat]

I couldn't really say whether it will be good or not. They could hit a home run. It's better than the empty theatre that's there now.

But. I really wish something that was already DISNEY was going in there. Or at least something ABC.

As much as I enjoy the INDY attractions and STAR TOURS, they just feel out of place at DISNEY. And that's how I'll feel about IDOL. So, I'm pretty wishy washy. I'd hate to see INDY and STAR TOURS someplace else. But IDOL feels like something better suited for SIX FLAGS.