Great response! You definitely make some good points.
I always say that most of this comes down to personal preference, aesthetics, etc. I personally think that this resort looks like it is going to be a beautiful place to stay with great amenities, especially for a standalone DVC. I just don't feel that the point charts should be similar to GFV (and not just because it is my home resort
). There are just too many
immediate amenities at the GF that beats out most other resorts for me. They can charge however much they want per point (and of course we know that they will), but for the number of points to be the same for these resorts is a bit of a stretch to me, IMHO. When my wife and I saw how many points they are estimating it will be for one night in a tower room - fold down bed/love seat combo, no sink area - that should in no way be as many points as they are anticipating. That right there pretty much turned us off from buying in, or using our existing points there (we currently have no resale points).
What I couldn't remember when discussing all of this with my better half is the reliability of the gondolas during storms. Lightning strikes can stop the monorails from running. Are these capable of running during thunder storms? I can see people purposefully avoiding the gondolas when storms are in the area. I personally can't wait to ride on them but my wife is not a fan. I think that the monorail resorts have more allure then the resorts along the gondola route. The gondolas have not been universally well received. If they had announced that they were adding new monorail loops, every Disney fan would have lost their mind. But you do make a strong argument on your side. I will be fascinated to see how fast (or slow) the points are sold at this one.