sedati
Well-Known Member
As much as I love that Citizen Kane meme (and far moreso the movie which I saw long before it was made into one), i must admit it's kind of ironic how it has come to be used given the context of the scene in the movie-
http://usvsth3m.com/post/60436953054/the-orson-welles-clapping-reaction-gif-is-everywhere
In this instance, I will take this opportunity to use the scene's proper context to describe people who applaud decisions such as Frozen at Norway. Those stubbornly and angrily clapping and singing praise because they've invested too much of their pride and emotion into something to admit the truth of the matter- who and what they're applauding just isn't any good (not anymore anyways).
There's a rather huge difference between including Mickey in a Fantasia short and gutting Maelstrom to replace it with Frozen. The story of the Sorcerer's Apprentice was kept intact and pretty faithfully represented and celebrated. Despite Mickey taking the place of the main character.
And even more glaring is the disparity of quality between the Frozen overlay and Fantasia. Fantasia and the Sorcerer's Apprentice were created with the maximum level of quality generally delivered during the Walt Disney era of animated feature films (it's considered by many as a classic and a true piece of art). Mickey himself was basically an actor in a story, familiar as a face yes but taking on a completely different role from what we were used to. That in itself was a rather novel and unique idea. And his role in the short was respectful of the story, his Mickey identity didn't detract from it.
Frozen at Norway is being created with the cheapest of budgets and the least amount of effort possible in order to cash in on a decent but massively overrated movie. A movie that despite my initial enjoyment of, is fast beginning to overstay its welcome.
Good point about Kane... though you should remember the film was about a man who, despite spending both a very long lifetime (years of development) and an incredible fortune (humongous E-ticket) could not rekindle the only fond memories he has, (the Disney of your youth) playing with his (SPOILER!) sled. If only Disney had a property that featured a sled (two in fact, as one explodes.)
I was hoping they would do this right, but reading the second half of your response tells me they did not (which is weird as from where I am in time, the original Maelstrom is still open and all that's been announced is an overlay. Are you a Timelord? Budget, effort, and over-ratedness hasn't even happened yet. How may pages is this thread in your time (2016?) I already have five more to slog though.