Disney (and others) at the Box Office - Current State of Affairs

Vegas Disney Fan

Well-Known Member
They much be a bunch of idiots to be so far off in their expectations. Do you think they are trying with all their might to pander to their audience but they just don't know who they should be pandering to?
I think it‘s a problem primarily created by too many likeminded people in one company with not enough dissenting voices to tell them their ideas will work great in places like CA and NY but will struggle in the rest of the country, and most of the world.

I would call them out of touch with the real world rather than idiots.

I think they are making what “Hollywood” wants to see and genuinely think they are making what the world wants to see.
 

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
I think it‘s a problem primarily created by too many likeminded people in one company with not enough dissenting voices to tell them their ideas will work great in places like CA and NY but will struggle in the rest of the country, and most of the world.

I would call them out of touch with the real world rather than idiots.

I think they are making what “Hollywood” wants to see and genuinely think they are making what the world wants to see.
See I think it’s not a matter of “location”…

Because “honoring Alabama”…or China for that matter…is silly. There are many people on this rock who are currently taking “pride” in pushing regression. It’s not the first time in our history and won’t be the last…
But ultimately they’ll all die and the movement will be forgotten. Progress is a biological tendency…not a campaign slogan. It’s a force of nature that never is denied for long.

I believe it’s more of pace. The most progress on society is made by making it strategically…it gives the “norms” more time to equalize.

There are alot of examples…but they’re mostly political
 

Chi84

Premium Member
I think it‘s a problem primarily created by too many likeminded people in one company with not enough dissenting voices to tell them their ideas will work great in places like CA and NY but will struggle in the rest of the country, and most of the world.

I would call them out of touch with the real world rather than idiots.

I think they are making what “Hollywood” wants to see and genuinely think they are making what the world wants to see.
I’ve been visiting Disney for almost 40 years now and I’ve always seen them as more of a leader than a follower. I don’t think they’re as clueless as people make them out to seem.

I may be wrong, but I don’t think they’re shocked that some of their recent movies haven’t been as popular as in the past. Change comes slowly. Maybe they’re looking to the future.
 

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
I’ve been visiting Disney for almost 40 years now and I’ve always seen them as more of a leader than a follower. I don’t think they’re as clueless as people make them out to seem.

I may be wrong, but I don’t think they’re shocked that some of their recent movies haven’t been as popular as in the past. Change comes slowly. Maybe they’re looking to the future.
The current management displays the air of “cluelessness” at present

When it doesn’t work…it doesn’t work
 

Tony the Tigger

Well-Known Member
I think it‘s a problem primarily created by too many likeminded people in one company with not enough dissenting voices to tell them their ideas will work great in places like CA and NY but will struggle in the rest of the country, and most of the world.

I would call them out of touch with the real world rather than idiots.

I think they are making what “Hollywood” wants to see and genuinely think they are making what the world wants to see.
I think they are reflecting reality, especially the logical continuation of reality stemming from the last 30+ years of history. Nobody expected this country to take a sudden jog in a certain direction like an errant hurricane. But ultimately, we will get over this hiccup, and the flyover states will have to wake up and deal with the reality that exists, namely: people other than straight white people belong in this country and will be reflected in films, including films "for" children.
 

TP2000

Well-Known Member
That’s a pretty impressive haul for a 29 year old movie

Isn't it? Since the re-release of The Nightmare Before Christmas opened on October 20th, 2023 it has done $8.4 Million at the box office. Assuming that Disney got an optimistic 60% take of that box office, it created an even $5 Million in profit for Disney from this latest re-release so far. Although it's fading fast in theaters now, so it apparently is more a Halloween thing and not a Christmas thing.

This is actually its 6th re-release from Disney in theaters, after previous theatrical re-releases in 2000, '06, '07, '08 and 2020.

The Nightmare Before Christmas earned $45 Million during its 1993 theatrical run, and then has made an additional $42 Million off of it's 6 subsequent re-releases in the 2000's and now 2020's. It's most successful re-release was in 2007, when it pulled in about $11 Million during its six week run in October/November of 2007.

All of those dollar figures are not adjusted for inflation, by the way.

 

Casper Gutman

Well-Known Member
The Marvels will tank. People hated Secret Invasion so Nick Fury will have no impact. Nobody cares about Kamala Kahn and people have forgotten who Monica Rambeau is. And Captain Marvel was only held up by the Infinity saga. There's no build up or anticipation for this movie.

Wish should do well as a holiday movie that might spark some Frozen or Encanto type feeling.

Then we're in for a movie desert. The strike has put everything on ice so everything that had been made will be delayed and everything that studios hoped to make will have to wait a long time for production to start.
I really like Ms Marvel, and so do a great many of the people who gave the series a chance - she's the most charismatic character in the MCU after Downey's Iron Man and her performance was universally critically acclaimed. In fact, I like the MCU in general, even if I think a few of their recent products have been lackluster. Unfortunately, these boards have been taken over by glib little trolls who delight in rooting for the failure of things people like regardless of quality, things that more often then not the trolls haven't seen. It's astoundingly small and petty, often driven by a desire to harm a perceived political "enemy."

WDWMagic used to be a pleasant respite from the general sewer that is social media, a place where critical discussion could occur without animus or hidden agenda, but that's been changing rapidly due to national events. We can't discuss that openly, of course, so instead we get a slow rot, with bad faith and petty cruelty pushing out informed conversation. It's a genuine shame.
 

TP2000

Well-Known Member
I think it‘s a problem primarily created by too many likeminded people in one company with not enough dissenting voices to tell them their ideas will work great in places like CA and NY but will struggle in the rest of the country, and most of the world.

Again, you swoop in with the succinct summary of facts. That's it exactly.

I have mentioned several times the Silver Lake Brunch Crowd, a group of proudly childless and well educated white collar folks who inhabit the hipster LA enclave of Silver Lake and mostly work at the various movie studios just over the hill in Burbank and Studio City. I am not too proud to admit that when I lived in SoCal until a year ago, I have been to brunch a few times in those places with some of those exact folks who work in "the industry". Some even sat at my table, as friends-of-friends. :eek:

They are often witty and savvy people to have brunch with, but their world view is incredibly narrow. Shockingly so. Some of the most provincial people in America live in LA, after all. They truly do believe that the rest of the country thinks like them and lives like them, and if they do not, they must aspire to think and live like them. There are many ways to describe that; a mind-meld, a borg, a hive-mind, a cult, or just plain clueless. With a big dollop of elitist snobbery on top. Let's order another round of Mimosas for the table and celebrate our audience who has abandoned us! 🥳

But it does make for an entertaining brunch, if only to laugh at them on the drive home.

These are the Silver Lake Brunch Crowd, who approve and create and market these new movies for Disney and then wonder why not enough American families show up at theaters for their film to break even. Disney has lost $800 Million at the box office so far in 2023 because of this childless and elitist crowd...

Alimento1_resize.jpg


I would call them out of touch with the real world rather than idiots.

I think they are making what “Hollywood” wants to see and genuinely think they are making what the world wants to see.

It's worse than that. They are making what they think the table next to them at brunch wants to see. The results are obvious.
 

TP2000

Well-Known Member
I really like Ms Marvel, and so do a great many of the people who gave the series a chance - she's the most charismatic character in the MCU after Downey's Iron Man and her performance was universally critically acclaimed. In fact, I like the MCU in general, even if I think a few of their recent products have been lackluster. Unfortunately, these boards have been taken over by glib little trolls who delight in rooting for the failure of things people like regardless of quality, things that more often then not the trolls haven't seen. It's astoundingly small and petty, often driven by a desire to harm a perceived political "enemy."

There's about one dozen of us posting in this thread regularly. There's probably three dozen more who stop in and skim, maybe drop a Like or two or an occasional comment, and then go back to doing laundry.

So... are you under the impression that the success or failure of The Marvels at the global box office is being determined by the one dozen regular posters here in this backwater sub-forum on a theme park website? Or for that matter, we're responsible for all of Disney's last 9 lavishly funded movies that never broke even at the box office and lost $800 Million in calendar year 2023?

I mean, I was once described as the man who overthrew Michael Eisner and elevated Bob Iger to his rightful place on the throne simply by my gin-soaked posts here. But I had no idea we had that much power to control the global box office too! o_O
 

Chi84

Premium Member
Unfortunately, these boards have been taken over by glib little trolls who delight in rooting for the failure of things people like regardless of quality, things that more often then not the trolls haven't seen. It's astoundingly small and petty, often driven by a desire to harm a perceived political "enemy."
I don’t think the boards have been taken over by trolls, and there really aren’t that many of them. It just seems so because of how often the same ones post the same tired stuff.

It’s possible to have substantive discussions with people who think differently than you, but some aren’t posting in good faith. It’s best not to engage with them.
 

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
I really like Ms Marvel, and so do a great many of the people who gave the series a chance - she's the most charismatic character in the MCU after Downey's Iron Man and her performance was universally critically acclaimed. In fact, I like the MCU in general, even if I think a few of their recent products have been lackluster. Unfortunately, these boards have been taken over by glib little trolls who delight in rooting for the failure of things people like regardless of quality, things that more often then not the trolls haven't seen. It's astoundingly small and petty, often driven by a desire to harm a perceived political "enemy."

WDWMagic used to be a pleasant respite from the general sewer that is social media, a place where critical discussion could occur without animus or hidden agenda, but that's been changing rapidly due to national events. We can't discuss that openly, of course, so instead we get a slow rot, with bad faith and petty cruelty pushing out informed conversation. It's a genuine shame.

…I’m so sorry you wasted the time to post this rant.

These boards…if you even care about reality…haven’t been “taken over” by anyone.
What’s happened with the studios is Disney has failed to hit the audience that is available to it for profitability for its movie slate with alarming regularity. So they’re losing money.
There can be multiple reasons why?…but none of them include “negative Nancy” on WDWMAGIC. They’re just tanking and there is reaction to it.

There’s still plenty of threads that do the ardent Disney support things…even in what can’t be disputed is a “down period”.
Stop whining about the reality and exaggerating the forum. Trip reports are available. 👍🏻
 
Last edited:

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
I don’t think the boards have been taken over by trolls, and there really aren’t that many of them. It just seems so because of how often the same ones post the same tired stuff.

It’s possible to have substantive discussions with people who think differently than you, but some aren’t posting in good faith. It’s best not to engage with them.
The numbers don’t look good. “Lack of faith” is trying to twist them or move the goal posts as to what determines “box office success”

The Shawshank redemption was a flop when release in the theaters…but is now considered one of the finest films ever made…

…this thread features nothing like that.
 

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
It's worse than that. They are making what they think the table next to them at brunch wants to see. The results are obvious.

I don’t think they’re actively trying to alienate…but I also think they don’t understand at all that they are alienating? If that makes any sense. The results are the same.

What’s developed heavily -at least in the US - is a really deep distrust of “affluency” by what can be poorly described as “common folk”

They may not really understand why they feel they are being marginalized…but their survival instinct kicks in on a wide swath of society/social trends and a staunch need to “protect themselves”

I can think of one YUGE political event in recent times that encapsulates this phenomenon brilliantly. Textbook.

Disney is dealing with this on a day to day basis now. It’s a major operational hindrance. And I don’t think the aloofness is “Intentional” from the sect you described…which maybe makes it more dangerous to TWDC?

They may fare better if they say “we aren’t supporting tradional tropes in film anymore…because we don’t feel it’s the best business strategy - so it’s up to you to decide if you want to continue to support us?”

Even “simple folk” would get the honesty, process the “slight” if they feel one…and possibly decide to continue en masse with some time?
Honesty still gets you a good deal of respect. Not trying to say “same ole Disney” and running D+ 30 minute specials occasionally to highlight “just how awesome we are…did you know it’s a 100 “anniversary” of something we want to promote arbitrarily …again?” 🙄
Things are different…why deny that?
 

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
I mean, I was once described as the man who overthrew Michael Eisner and elevated Bob Iger to his rightful place on the throne simply by my gin-soaked posts here. But I had no idea we had that much power to control the global box office too! o_O

…and I was the “unmagical wet blanket” who warned on other forums that the “problem” wasn’t - in fact - solved at all with that elevation.

So it’s my fault that it’s being proven correct. Just me and poison tongue under weird assumed Alias read by dozens of Uber fans on a chat forum…

We should have tea 🫖and talk about the raw power we wield, Darth.
 

Tha Realest

Well-Known Member
There's about one dozen of us posting in this thread regularly. There's probably three dozen more who stop in and skim, maybe drop a Like or two or an occasional comment, and then go back to doing laundry.

So... are you under the impression that the success or failure of The Marvels at the global box office is being determined by the one dozen regular posters here in this backwater sub-forum on a theme park website? Or for that matter, we're responsible for all of Disney's last 9 lavishly funded movies that never broke even at the box office and lost $800 Million in calendar year 2023?

I mean, I was once described as the man who overthrew Michael Eisner and elevated Bob Iger to his rightful place on the throne simply by my gin-soaked posts here. But I had no idea we had that much power to control the global box office too! o_O
Don’t you see?

It’s a few WDWMagic posters that are to blame for the dwindling career prospects of Iman Vellani - and not the creators that featured her in the least-watched MCU series and, based on the Variety article, a film that’s been received as “middling” and stands to have the worst financial performance of any MCU film.
 

erasure fan1

Well-Known Member
"Haven’t watched it" - tell me why I should finish reading that post - is anything new?

“Wasn’t what most wanted from Disney” is both inaccurate and irrelevant to my points.

If churning out bad movies because the premise gets people in the seats for the first weekend is a business model of value to society, I don’t know what to tell you.
Tell me again why you didn't make time to go see it in the theater again? Nothing I said is off base. We saw a significant drop off from the other renaissance remake films. I didn't call the film bad. I said it wasn't what most wanted. If it was the film most fans wanted, why did we see such a big drop? It didn't do near what it should have.
If churning out bad movies because the premise gets people in the seats for the first weekend is a business model of value to society, I don’t know what to tell you.
If churning out great films such as mermaid can't get one of Disneys biggest defenders into the theater, I don't know what to tell you. I'm not really sure why wanting Disney to make higher quality movies and tv series is such a controversial take with you.
So... are you under the impression that the success or failure of The Marvels at the global box office is being determined by the one dozen regular posters here in this backwater sub-forum on a theme park website? Or for that matter, we're responsible for all of Disney's last 9 lavishly funded movies that never broke even at the box office and lost $800 Million in calendar year 2023?
Absolutely he is, as well as a group of others on here. It's just easier to blame the audience than to actually hold Disney to a higher quality standard. It's always the same take, "you hate star wars and marvel because you're anti diversity!!!" Yet when examples of these same "toxic" fans fully embracing diversity gets completely ignored.
 

Casper Gutman

Well-Known Member
Tell me again why you didn't make time to go see it in the theater again? Nothing I said is off base. We saw a significant drop off from the other renaissance remake films. I didn't call the film bad. I said it wasn't what most wanted. If it was the film most fans wanted, why did we see such a big drop? It didn't do near what it should have.

If churning out great films such as mermaid can't get one of Disneys biggest defenders into the theater, I don't know what to tell you. I'm not really sure why wanting Disney to make higher quality movies and tv series is such a controversial take with you.

Absolutely he is, as well as a group of others on here. It's just easier to blame the audience than to actually hold Disney to a higher quality standard. It's always the same take, "you hate star wars and marvel because you're anti diversity!!!" Yet when examples of these same "toxic" fans fully embracing diversity gets completely ignored.
Read the boards. Actually read what they say, not what you want them to say because you don’t want to believe the truth about a lot of posters that agree with you. We’re told Disneys entire output is terrible. But are we given critical assessments of what’s wrong with the films? Discussions of cinematographic or directorial choices? No, the ONLY thing we’re told, over and over, is that the films are too woke, or, more often, that they “don’t give the audience what they want” (wink wink).

What, for instance, is the problem with Ms Marvel, a critically acclaimed series? The star wasn’t hot enough, obviously. The white males who rightfully own the franchise didn’t for her. It didn’t star more universally acceptable actors like Evans or Downey (acceptable because wink wink). It didn’t give the audience “what they want” (wink wink). No comments on story structure, performances, directing… no indication that critics have seen anything other then pictures of the Star or the name of the studio, which, amazingly, were enough to form a definite opinion (wink, wink).

And of course we all have to pretend that a national culture war unlike anything we’ve seen since the 60s, a movement that has elected multiple high office holders and effects every single corner of our culture, couldn’t possibly be motivating the posters here or effecting the fortunes of a studio that is being directly attacked by multiple news channels, commentators, powerful politicians… no we all play dumb. And the only criticism of those “terrible” Disney films is that they didn’t give the audience “what they want” (wink wink).
 
Last edited:

ABQ

Well-Known Member
I don’t think they’re actively trying to alienate…but I also think they don’t understand at all that they are alienating? If that makes any sense. The results are the same.
With regards to these folks, and it 100% carries over to the powers that be at TWDC, is hubris, they are all guilty of believing they can all do no wrong. They are oblivious to the fact that anyone wouldn't enjoy the product they put out as they cannot fathom the concept that anything they produce is not the greatest thing you've ever witnessed.
 

Sirwalterraleigh

Premium Member
With regards to these folks, and it 100% carries over to the powers that be at TWDC, is hubris, they are all guilty of believing they can all do no wrong. They are oblivious to the fact that anyone wouldn't enjoy the product they put out as they cannot fathom the concept that anything they produce is not the greatest thing you've ever witnessed.

The “H” word is getting assigned to the house of dwarf with more and more regularity these days
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom