I agree...all of this is just opinions!! Even after seeing the two pictures, I still love the hat!! If I wanted to be in Hollywood, I would go to Hollywood. I like Disney's version of Hollywood.
I grew up going to Disney, but did not go during the "college" years. I had never seen DHS without the hat, so until two years ago, I never knew the hat was not always there. But now, after seeing the pictures, I still love the hat. Other people do not...that's great!! There are many things about Disney that appeal to some and not others!! That's why it appeals to so many!!
I originally posted that I like the reference to Sorcerer Mickey, and that children enjoy the hat. Not all children are familiar with Fantasia, but most children are familiar with Sorcerer Mickey-from Fantasmic, merchandising, and the hat!! How many children are walking around WDW right now with the sorcerer hat on? And it's not from Fantasia, it's from DHS!!
It may be commercialism, but Disney is commercial!! So many rides you exit have a shop to go along with it...but that's fine with me!! Disney's rides, shows, and products all have a whimsical, magical quality to me.
I understand that some great Disney fans find the hat misplaced, but for my family and I, we have our picture taken in front of it every year!!