Now Tiki, though? Unless it's a super packed day, I only ever ever a dozen or so people in there... I've also never understood the defense for Tiki Room and not CBJ. Of the two, I think CBJ is more entertaining. But I guess that's just an opinion.
I think Tiki Room is defended by some who don't defend CBJ because:
1. It's the first AA show and it can be more directly tied to Walt than CBJ can (his "last laugh" may have been in reference to CBJ concepts, but the show as it was then and the show that opened in 1971 are not 1:1).
2. Many things that started in Florida and moved to other places are inherently treated as 'lesser' by some people than things that started in CA-arguably Space Mountain is the only thing that opened first in FL and later moved elsewhere that everybody loves. All because Disneyland was the first one, which some construe to mean the 'important' one, so
obviously it's more important if it opened at Disneyland first. And on a related note:
3. If the show never really caught on at Disneyland the same way as it did elsewhere (and has been closed in California for over 20 years, and last played the OG show even more long ago than that), obviously it must be because it's "inferior art" and people who like it must be morons. So goes the logic for some people, anyway.
4. Long-standing bias that some segment of the population will always feel against country music and/or the people who listen to country music.
I would agree that more often than not, there have been more people in CBJ showings than Tiki Room in my experience. There's a reason that Tiki Room got converted to UNM, but when CBJ changed to Vacation Hoedown it proved short-lived because people wanted the original show back. There are plenty of people who are Florida/WDW based that clearly prefer the Bears over the Tiki Room-but the people who make the decisions are in California, and likewise assume that DL is always correct and MK is always the flawed sequel while subscribing to additional biases noted above. So anyone who prefers the Bears over the Tiki Room probably seems incomprehensible to them, even if the numbers and history might point to that reality.