Coronavirus and Walt Disney World general discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.

DisneyCane

Well-Known Member
The overall number of NYPD deaths from Covid-19 is currently at 61. The force is 36,000 sworn officers. That is .0017 percent. The population of NYC is approx 8.8 million. There have been 56,000 covid-19 deaths in NYC. That is .0064 percent. So overall NYPD has faired better than the general population.
Likely due to the age range of an NYPD officer being lower than the age range for the general population.
 

October82

Well-Known Member
Thanks for the fact check. This makes sense to me.
What does not make sense to me is NYPD being forced to vaccinate or lose their jobs.

Police and firefighters both interact with vulnerable parts of the population on a more consistent basis than other groups. They may not be at high risks for severe health outcomes, but they are at high risk for transmitting the virus to people who are likely to have a severe health outcome.

Vaccines are a public health tool - they protect others in addition to yourself. Mandates are about public health, not personal.
 

Bullseye1967

Is that who I am?
Premium Member
Can you explain what relevance you think the fact that NYPD doesn't employ children has to the conversation?
The post I was responding to refered to the officers being younger than many in the general population who died of Covid-19. I was pointing out while that is true, the demographic with the fewest deaths is not represented in NYPD either. I will add the quote to my response for clarity.


Edit: it is already quoted.
 

BuddyThomas

Well-Known Member
We can be thankful that the vast majority who get covid do survive, many with little or no symptoms. In the case of your neighbor, he and his family now have natural immunity, so that's good.

It's too bad folks that had COVID, survived and now have natural immunity, are still forced to get the vaccine or lose their jobs...
I might be misinterpreting you last few posts, but it sounds like you’re trying to trivialize the pandemic and that’s not cool. 746,000 Americans and counting have died of this and if you don’t think that’s a big deal, I don’t know what to tell you. Also, your statement about having natural immunity after having COVID is flawed. Every single study that has been done says that it is possible to be reinfected after having had COVID.
 

Andrew C

You know what's funny?
No one ever said mandates were going to be easy. Even though I support some, it’s definitely not a black and white situation as maybe some want it to be. Just as their are consequences for not mandating, there are consequences when you do mandate.
 

MisterPenguin

President of Animal Kingdom
Premium Member
I understand many businesses are mandating the vaccine that's fine. But for these essential NYC workers, to me its different and I agree, should have been handled better.

I would have thought their unions would have been stronger.

Not all unions are against a vaccine mandate. Many were totally on board, including police and fire fighter unions.

Some unions are OK with the mandates, but didn't like that they were bypassed in negotiations. Some, just to retain power, others, with a real desire to protect some of their workers who couldn't get vaccinated and to hash out penalties and grounds for being fired.

The union leadership that are totally against a mandate need to check in with their constituents whom they're supposed to be representing. The majority got vaccinated and may not be happy with their union leadership being anti-science and anti-vax.
 

Heppenheimer

Well-Known Member
Back to matters purely COVID...

For those wondering about the protection of prior infection versus vaccination, here's the answer. And one of many reasons why prior infection won't be considered a substitute for full vaccination:


In short, vaccination provides 5x the protection of prior infection. We've kind of suspected this would be the case for awhile, because the antibody response to prior infection is far more variable than from vaccination. Here's the data that shows the results.

Like all things, though, we'll learn more as time goes on. It is possible that the protection from vaccination eventually fades below prior infection (a possibility mentioned by the study's authors), but at least as long as we've had the vaccines, they're offering more protection for now.
 

ToTBellHop

Well-Known Member
Not all unions are against a vaccine mandate. Many were totally on board, including police and fire fighter unions.

Some unions are OK with the mandates, but didn't like that they were bypassed in negotiations. Some, just to retain power, others, with a real desire to protect some of their workers who couldn't get vaccinated and to hash out penalties and grounds for being fired.

The union leadership that are totally against a mandate need to check in with their constituents whom they're supposed to be representing. The majority got vaccinated and may not be happy with their union leadership being anti-science and anti-vax.
My union said they supported vaccination (and kept telling us we should get the shot) but not the mandate. They suggested it was an attempt from the Board to take away our voice.

Then they surveyed us all and suddenly supported the mandate as long as it also applied to students. Who would have expected a union of college professors to support science???
 

Disstevefan1

Well-Known Member
At the beginning of the pandemic, our essential workers were held up as the heros that they truly are. Along comes the vaccine mandates and our heros are suddenly….. expendable…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom