FrankLapidus
Well-Known Member
I love how this contract debate pops up here every 6 months or so
And it no doubt will again when the new Avengers and Ant-Man films are released.
I love how this contract debate pops up here every 6 months or so
Well this thread took a southbound turn pretty fast. Guys politics have their place and it's definitely not here.
Given that you're literally now comparing Happy Feet to Nazi propaganda, I will simply say that I certainly hope you enjoy Black Panther, as it's a terrific film, and I will back away quietly.
Yes, that's correct. You said that Happy Feet was the same sort of propaganda that Hitler used. There's really no other way to interpret that.Right. I compared Happy Feet to Nazi propaganda.
I would suggest that you're seeing it from a defiantly caucasian perspective, considering that you insist it would be the exact same film if the black people were replaced by martians.Its a movie about magical space rocks set against a super hero version of the Lion King...
Yes, that's correct. You said that Happy Feet was the same sort of propaganda that Hitler used. There's really no other way to interpret that.
I would suggest that you're seeing it from a defiantly caucasian perspective, considering that you insist it would be the exact same film if the black people were replaced by martians.
What director Rich Moore had to say in an interview before the movie was even releasedGo ahead and color me however you like, but you have me all wrong.
I consume political commentary every day; in what I read and in what I watch. I have my opinions, but I'm always interested in the other side - maybe they can teach me something, or at least help me to understand their point of view. When I'm consuming political thought, I'm in that frame of mind and ready for any wacky thing that might come along.
When I go to see a movie with my kids that has been billed as simple family entertainment, I don't like to be blindsided by propaganda. Happy Feet was pure propaganda: espousing a particular opinion with complete disregard to contrary views in order to shape naive minds. (Hitler was good at this.) Zootopia wasn't as bad as HF, as there are lots of things in it that I agree with politically; but it was so ham-handed and unrelenting...when I just came to see the cute bunny and the other animals be funny. I've been twice fooled by these "cutesie" films, so I go in with my eyes wide open now.
Black Panther is a film about black people made by Disney; OF COURSE it will have a political agenda. I'm going in ready for the debate, not just to be entertained by the super hero. I'm sure that I will enjoy it, as I have most Disney/Marvel films. In addition, I hear that it addresses "walls" we put up between ourselves and urges black empowerment. Both of these subjects need encouragement in our society. Perhaps I will like the politics it preaches.
...but either way, I'm ready for the sermon.
Actually it's an adaptation of The Magnificent Seven (which was an adaptation of Seven Samurai, etc etc) so I see what you mean. I also think that a lot of Black people consider this movie deeply empowering and inspiring because of its afro-centric themes.Bugs Life is almost a shot for shot remake of Three Amigos.
I'm confused, are you saying that if the world and setting are fictional then the story cannot have a underlying theme that is both current and political?Its fictional. I don't need a racial point of view to objectively say that. Its not a story like "Hidden Figures", "Straight out of Compton" or even Roots (fictional, but grounded in reality).
There are magical space rocks serving as a McGuffin, there is a 100% fictional land with future tech, there is a magical space rock infused herb that grants super powers located in a universe that includes a guy who can shrink to subatomic levels, a guy who is a literal Norse god and a purple space monster chasing magical space rocks that have the power to create and destroy universes.
The adult in me realized that this is a fantasy and the same story has been told many times over going back to Hamlet. Its a good movie, based on a 500 year old trope, told in a new and refreshing way. As I said, you can literally throw anybody into it and it wont change the overall themes of the movie.
We do this all the time...Bugs Life is almost a shot for shot remake of Three Amigos. Lion King was just hamlet with animals. Avatar is just Pocahontas, which was Dances With wolves before that. The only thing different is the packaging and the marketing.
Its fictional. I don't need a racial point of view to objectively say that. Its not a story like "Hidden Figures", "Straight out of Compton" or even Roots (fictional, but grounded in reality).
There are magical space rocks serving as a McGuffin, there is a 100% fictional land with future tech, there is a magical space rock infused herb that grants super powers located in a universe that includes a guy who can shrink to subatomic levels, a guy who is a literal Norse god and a purple space monster chasing magical space rocks that have the power to create and destroy universes.
The adult in me realized that this is a fantasy and the same story has been told many times over going back to Hamlet. Its a good movie, based on a 500 year old trope, told in a new and refreshing way. As I said, you can literally throw anybody into it and it wont change the overall themes of the movie.
We do this all the time...Bugs Life is almost a shot for shot remake of Three Amigos. Lion King was just hamlet with animals. Avatar is just Pocahontas, which was Dances With wolves before that. The only thing different is the packaging and the marketing.
I'm confused, are you saying that if the world and setting are fictional then the story cannot have a underlying theme that is both current and political?
Fantasy and Sci-fi literature often delve into social and political commentary. One of the benefits of writing or storytelling in the genre is the ability to use fantastical realities to showcase the theme allowing the view/reader separation from the "now" to gain insight without preconceived bias.
Actually it's an adaptation of The Magnificent Seven (which was an adaptation of Seven Samurai, etc etc) so I see what you mean. I also think that a lot of Black people consider this movie deeply empowering and inspiring because of its afro-centric themes.
Or it is super fortunate that Disney didnt get a chance to ruin their own theme parks sooner.Thats unfortunate, i cant see Uni ever letting it go in that case.
Different families and friends take different things away from films, clearly.In all seriousness, none of my friends, family or any other black folk are having these "deep" philosophical discussions on the hidden meaning of the movie.
Of course, sometimes a fantasy film is just fantasy. But I think you are selling the genre and specifically this film short, at least for it's cultural resonance. Or I could send you a few dozen links attributing to the films social reach as a defining moment for many demographics.We're saying that some times a fantasy movie is just that Fantasy without any dark, deep, destroy the little one's psyche.
They recently spent a small fortune repainting the buildings with "3D paint".Agreed. I'm sure the Universal Brass know that the Marvel area looks dated and cheap..
I'm baffled by all the political talk here. Sometimes a giant movie blockbuster is just a giant movie blockbuster.
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.