I love my steak dinner and, in the lat ten years, we've eaten at just about every TS that serves steak. The best so far would have to be the Strip or Poterhouse at Yachtsmen. Oddly enough, around 97-98, I would have said the molasses-crusted T-bone at Tony's but they stopped serving that years ago. Narcoosse's has also been right up there, I would choose that over CG or Cellier.
We ate at California Grill in November and it was the best steak any of us had ever had. I could have cut it with a butter knife. The view was awesome and the wait staff was outstanding. We will return again
We eat at the Yachtsman all the time. The Filet mignon is the best we have ever had. It's so good i will not try anything else on the menu. But save room for desert its also great. If you go ask to have Rickey as your waiter. He is by far the best!!!
I know you said Orlando but if you can go one hour west to Tampa go to Bern's Steak House. Best steak, French onion soup, vegatables, salad, etc. anywhere.
I love Le Cellier, but being a local, you can't really beat Manny's Chophouse in Haines City (on US 27 - about 15 minutes from WDW). For the price, the quality of the steaks is amazing! My wife and I share a 14oz steak there and usually end up eating for about $25.00!
We always eat at the Yachtsmans when we are @ Disney. The steaks are divine!! Last year I was so sick that I didn't even touch my steak. We took it back to the room and had it for breakfast the next morning b/c I felt sooo much better. The steak reheated in a microwave was still better than most of the steaks I've had anywhere else!