The reality is... you can't take people's reports at face value because honestly most people don't even know what the working condition really looks like.
From first hand experience I can report that I was amazed about the details and effects I saw on Splash Mountain, a ride that I had first seen in 2004 and since then had many rides on it. I could tell in 2011 that there were things lacking as compared to what I had seen before. But when I saw the refurbished Splash Mountain I realised that there were things that I had never seen before.
Dinosaur on the other hand is a ride that I usually suffered through with closed eyes (I am easily scared by sudden noises and movements). Only on my last trip in 2011 I started to appreciate it. And when I rode it this spring even I noticed that things were missing or not moving. And it felt more generally empty.