Cesar R M
Well-Known Member
the "untouchable and flawless" syndrome?On December 18, Rich Greenfield of BTIG downgraded Disney stock. Disney CEO Bob Iger wasn't pleased with the downgrade, making the following very public statement when questioned about it during a December 21 interview on Bloomberg TV:
Well, I was curious or suspicious about the timing. If anybody wanted headlines the time to do it was the morning after "Star Wars" opened in the United States. And so it was headline grabbing. The analyst who came out with that report has been wrong about us on a number of occasions. And so one would have to question if he's been wrong so often before, you know, how valid were his comments this time around. And by the way, he's entitled to his opinions.
And the other thing I would say is I don't know where the accountability is. I don't know when he's wrong; I don't know who he's accountable for. But nothing has changed and we've got nothing to update since our last filing and our last earnings call regarding ESPN. So again, he's entitled to his opinions.
The response by the normally composed (some say dull) Iger caused murmurs among those who closely follow financial news and, in at least one case, lead to an unusual public commentary by Eric Jackson, Managing Director at Ader Investment Management.
On December 21, the Dow closed at 17251.62. Yesterday's close was 15988.08, a decline of 7.3%.
On December 21, Disney closed at 106.59. Yesterday's close was 93.90, a decline of 11.9%.
The markets are overreacting, they always do, but I have to admit that listening again to Iger's un-CEO-like response to Greenfield's prophetic downgrade concerns me.
Business people suck up to CEOs. Good CEOs expect it and learn to take everything with a grain of salt. However, after a while, many CEOs actually start to believe it and, as a result, their abilities to handle criticism declines.
I recall Michael Eisner becoming slowly unhinged after his first decade as Disney CEO, increasingly attacking those who differed with him. Now that Iger has been CEO for a decade, I'm beginning to wonder if we're starting to see the same with Iger.
I also hope that he doesn't go crazy with buybacks and cancelling most of the upgrades on the parks :/
Which is .. by itself.. pretty stupid.. considering how the parks are constantly printing money and might be their "fall back" if ESPN goes to the carp...