The original lands of Disneyland were built to tell a story. This alone differed them from the current mindset which has dominated Walt Disney Parks and Resorts, the franchise model where themed entertainment is reduced to an expensive form of advertising.
I want to clear up a few things about this (not picking on you, just using this to address some SW related things):
The original lands did tell a story of America's and Walt's past and its future and the imagination that allowed this country to move forward. While the argument could be made about SWL tying into the imagination that came out of this progress, there is no doubt that there are very, very few parties involved in SWL's development that in an ideal world would've placed SWL within DL proper. The need to put it there was born out of a very much arguable necessity.
Disneyland was always a vehicle to drive advertising for both Disney's brands and its sponsors. It's been that way from it's very inception. Where else do you think the theme park industry learned this?
Star Wars Land is the first land conceived and pushed forward specifically because it was demanded by third-party financial analysts.
This is not the correct way to think of it. Since Lucas and Eisner collaborated back in the 80's (and even before then as the demand for SW in Disney can be traced back to 1977), more Star Wars in Disney has always been what Guests have demanded. More SW would've come sooner had the Eisner/Lucas relationship not soured. While Iger would like to pat himself on the back about planting the seed of the sale in George's head, the truth is that Lucasfilm>Disney was something that was always stewing as George thought about retirement. I first heard of this during the filming of Episode III, so it was at least a "spark" of imagination all the way back in 2003-4. As soon as talks of the merger began, the wheels of developing more SW for the Parks began in earnest. It was only a question of when and where it would come and in what form.
Star Wars Land is also trying to achieve cost savings by being designed once and built twice in a way never before done. This means the scale is appropriate for Disney's Hollywood Studios but completely out of line with the rest of Disneyland.
Simply false. SWL from the ground up was always a DL project, simply because nobody wanted to wait for Orlando. In all three forms of its development, it was first and foremost designed to fit into DL and no real concessions were made to fit it in Florida (other than the 3rd attraction getting yanked because TDO is too cheap to pay for it). The first form for SWL was going to land right on top of a good portion of Tomorrowland and it was going to be a "Greatest Hits" tour of the SW galaxy. Nobody wanted this option. The 2nd version was the Toontown overlay and it was really close to being approved when the 3rd more elaborate option was finally settled on for it to reside where it is currently. When this move took place, it was the needs of Disneyland that took the only priority. Everything about this new space had to accommodate it's placement within DL. The very planet that this spaceport occupies is engineered to fit behind Rivers of America and blend in with Thunder's spires. SWL's placement in the swamps of DHS weren't even locked down until well after DL was already in motion. So, in essence, SWL's needs for Orlando weren't really factored into the design. Actually, one of the reasons I've heard with move from Echo Lake to the backlot were to make DL's design better fit into DHS as it's easier to hide the massive show buildings from the park entrance. Plus, this approach is ultimately cheaper/faster as getting SWL online won't require a massive parking project to be completed.
Last is the millennia old fallacy that one's legacy is heightened by altering and removing the physical works of your predecessors.
This last statement is very debatable. One does like to think of the Weatherman as being vain enough to want to plant the flag on the pinnacle of the SW mountain and lay claim that he delivered the nerds thorough the desert of Tatooine and reached the promised land of finally having more SW in the Parks. But, I think history will prove that his subordinates may have under minded his aspirations as best they could. I've mentioned time and again that most everyone involved in this project knew that putting SW into DL wasn't the right place to do it. It would've been far better suited as an anchor for the 3rd gate (I still think it will ultimately reside there as well). Unfortunately, waiting until that happens simply wasn't possible. Bob wants it done and as I've mentioned, the Guests have long wanted it. If you are wondering why DCA wasn't an option for SW to land there - it potentially could have; but, never was in serious discussion because if SW went to DCA, then Marvel would've come to DL and that would've been an even worse fit. So, faced with choices of making the square peg of SW fit in the round Death Star hole of DL - the Imagineers started to try to steer the project somewhere it would've had the least amount of impact... outside the berm.
So, with everything that could've gone wrong with this bitter pill. Where SWL ended up in DL is going to be done in the least impactful way. It doesn't change the fact that it didn't belong there to begin with and we are losing some of the length and isolation of the RoA; but, it does have a great number of positive impacts that it's opening will bring to the table:
- It will bring a new more dynamic backdrop to the RoA path with the waterfalls and new village.
- It will address the huge crowd control nightmare of the bottleneck the RoA created in trying to get people in and out of New Orleans Square and Critter Country.
- It is bringing a new Fantasmic to the table (I "think" this is going to be a great thing based on what I've been told; but, then again... it's a big risk to change something a great as DL's F!).
- It's bringing 2 E-tickets to DL and one of them should knock the socks off of even the most jaded fan (they both should, but, Alcatraz is going to be so good).
- It's adding a bunch of real estate for more guests to spread out in in a very Potter-esque detailed setting that will be great to spend hours in.
- The sharing of this land with WDW is going to force TDO's miserly ways of getting 2 E's and a land that they normally wouldn't have budgeted this much extravagance for.
and most importantly...
- The completion of this land and the assured success will greatly expedite Anaheim's future expansion towards a 3rd gate. Between it, Marvel, and the Fantasyland project - they will have mostly filled all of the existing property.
If you build it, they will come... at lightspeed.
Oh... and welcome back Spirit!