doctornick
Well-Known Member
The reason the MCU works and the reason Infinity War felt like a cash grab to you is that it is a cash grab. But, it is a cash grab that I like a lot. When I was reading a lot of comics (~1975-1995), a comic devoted to a specific hero or group would have a regular issue come out every month. Then, typically in the summer, a more expensive, longer, annual would come out. There would be a lot of cross over stuff in the annuals...Spider Man and the Wasp might appear in the Daredevil annual and to find out more about what they were doing a reader of Daredevil might pick those annuals up. Of course, in those annuals, other characters would appear and you get the idea. I think comics quit doing this in the mid or late 90s. Anyway, everyone knew these were big money makers, but fans LOVED them. Infinity War is essentially that annual after 18 earlier issues. This seems about right at the pace you can do movies. Actually, the rate at which these movies comes out is one of the many subtle things that make the MCU work. Instead of trying to Hollywoodize comics and super heroes, they did the opposite. What if we made the movies as much like the comics as humanly possible? What if we tell little stories more often? Also, like the comics, they just tweaked things a bit if it wasn't quite as big as a commercial or critical success as they wanted (see: Thor) instead of just giving up on the whole enterprise. People like me who liked comic books at some point in life intuitively recognize the formula and really like it. TBH, in many ways I consider the whole MCU quite a cinematic accomplishment. They've successfully created a textured, layered world where characters are very important (this is also important to comics because a drawn fight is only so interesting). They've created this universe so successfully that a giant outer space dwarf who uses a solar powered smithy and a talking raccoon are taken in stride. Visually, each of these movies has scenes where I can close my eyes and picture the panel or splash page (tons of splash pages in Infinity War, another annual feature). I would have had the urge to end Black Panther by turning the scene of BP and Killmonger watching the Wakandan sunset together into a comic book panel.
Anyway, as a 48 year old dude (I ain't Thor) I can understand the criticisms. As a regular reader of comics when I was younger, I really appreciate why this works.
Brilliant post and especially the highlighted. That gets the crux of how the MCU has succeeded IMHO -- by actually using the established comic book "formula" and directly adopting it for films. It's brilliant and yet simple. There's a reason why comic books have had an enduring role in the pop culture of the US and they've used that sensibility to entertain a mass audience who otherwise hasn't even realized they'd like that style of storytelling.
It's funny because Film Critic Hulk recently published a scathing article condemning Infinity War by being too much like comic book storytelling, when in fact I'd argue that capturing the essence of comic books is exactly why it works and resonates with some many people.