spacemt354
Chili's
Will the results be in today?
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
2016 Year End Event - Eisner's Game: An Imagineering Competition
- Thread starter kmbmw777
- Start date
Hopefully!
@Magic Feather
Your design didn't seem much like a living planet. Rather it was just a theme park on a planet. No description of the civilization that exists or what makes this new vast planet unique. While tourism is the main focus, it is not the sole thing. Also, you focused on only one type of tourism. I would've liked to see maybe some underwater adventures or cities!
@spacemt345
Your planet had some very beautiful landscapes but nothing that made it truly unique. The variety of landscapes made it feel like just another Earth. Also, I wished you focused a bit more on the civilization. I loved the Ariel tours though!
@FigmentPigments
I have nothing to say. This is beautiful. Perfect in every way. If the Lemon Trees were not already over, this would deserve a nomination. I love the Tommorow land area. I wish the Jungle Area got a little more love, but that's just not-picking. The detail and everything was fantastic.
@RMichael21 @tcool123
Did not submit
Your design didn't seem much like a living planet. Rather it was just a theme park on a planet. No description of the civilization that exists or what makes this new vast planet unique. While tourism is the main focus, it is not the sole thing. Also, you focused on only one type of tourism. I would've liked to see maybe some underwater adventures or cities!
@spacemt345
Your planet had some very beautiful landscapes but nothing that made it truly unique. The variety of landscapes made it feel like just another Earth. Also, I wished you focused a bit more on the civilization. I loved the Ariel tours though!
@FigmentPigments
I have nothing to say. This is beautiful. Perfect in every way. If the Lemon Trees were not already over, this would deserve a nomination. I love the Tommorow land area. I wish the Jungle Area got a little more love, but that's just not-picking. The detail and everything was fantastic.
@RMichael21 @tcool123
Did not submit
Disney Dad 3000
Well-Known Member
Greetings everyone. This is my first foray into judging, so here goes!
First just wanted to give kudos to @kmbmw777 for the prompts in this competition.
@Magic Feather
Pontus
When I first started reading your prompt, I thought we were going to get all sorts of exotic water locales, creatures and underwater adventures based on the planet being made up of so much water. I was a little disappointed that wasn't explored more based on the make up of the planet itself. I thought you did a nice job of giving a basic set up of the planet, how things were laid out, etc. Completely appreciate anyone that puts themselves out there and takes the time to do custom art work of any type. I felt like there was a good deal that was not explored though based on the prompt as far as more detail with the tourism and how was this truly a living park
@spacemt354
Forza One
You knocked out some of the basic backstory of the prompt with getting to your planet, government, and some excursions (some amazing stock photos btw). However you were missing some of the other features that would make this a living planet with the inhabitants, etc. While the natural planet excursions looked awesome, I was also looking for potentially some insights on attractions built for the planet whether they be monuments, themed attractions, etc.. In other words tourism that the locale might also enjoy. I know you were short on time, but thought you had a good start to a beautiful planet.
@FigmentPigments
D23
Not sure really to begin here with yours.
First I'll say your website was spot on. Felt you did a really nice job with the set up and would blend very similarly to local tourism websites for some large cities on Earth. I don't want to get too much into talking about your project because I fear I'll leave something awesome out. Really loved your attention to transportation and all of the different options that would be needed for a planet. You checked a lot of boxes with this project and to me really delivered something that I would almost expect to see in a team competition in a championship round but you did it yourself. I don't want to speak for kmb, but I think you really nailed the prompt and then some.
First just wanted to give kudos to @kmbmw777 for the prompts in this competition.
@Magic Feather
Pontus
When I first started reading your prompt, I thought we were going to get all sorts of exotic water locales, creatures and underwater adventures based on the planet being made up of so much water. I was a little disappointed that wasn't explored more based on the make up of the planet itself. I thought you did a nice job of giving a basic set up of the planet, how things were laid out, etc. Completely appreciate anyone that puts themselves out there and takes the time to do custom art work of any type. I felt like there was a good deal that was not explored though based on the prompt as far as more detail with the tourism and how was this truly a living park
@spacemt354
Forza One
You knocked out some of the basic backstory of the prompt with getting to your planet, government, and some excursions (some amazing stock photos btw). However you were missing some of the other features that would make this a living planet with the inhabitants, etc. While the natural planet excursions looked awesome, I was also looking for potentially some insights on attractions built for the planet whether they be monuments, themed attractions, etc.. In other words tourism that the locale might also enjoy. I know you were short on time, but thought you had a good start to a beautiful planet.
@FigmentPigments
D23
Not sure really to begin here with yours.
First I'll say your website was spot on. Felt you did a really nice job with the set up and would blend very similarly to local tourism websites for some large cities on Earth. I don't want to get too much into talking about your project because I fear I'll leave something awesome out. Really loved your attention to transportation and all of the different options that would be needed for a planet. You checked a lot of boxes with this project and to me really delivered something that I would almost expect to see in a team competition in a championship round but you did it yourself. I don't want to speak for kmb, but I think you really nailed the prompt and then some.
Results
5. @RMichael21 @tcool123
3. @Magic Feather
2. @spacemt354
AND THE 2016 Grand Champion is...
@FigmentPigments
5. @RMichael21 @tcool123
3. @Magic Feather
2. @spacemt354
AND THE 2016 Grand Champion is...
@FigmentPigments
spacemt354
Chili's
FigmentPigments
Well-Known Member
Thank you so much!!!
It's a real honor, not only to get my first win in a competition, but to work with and compete against some truly amazing armchair imagineers. Thank you to @kmbmw777 and all of the judges. What a way to start off the new year! Congratulations to all of the participants on a great game! 
FigmentPigments
Well-Known Member
Thank you! I'm so grateful.Congratulations Figment!
spacemt354
Chili's
Thank you for hosting as well and to all the judges! You did a great job as a first time host!
You, David, Magic Feather, and now Pi all first time hosts doing well!
FigmentPigments
Well-Known Member
Absolutely! It's great to see all of these new hosts taking a great step into making new comps and challenges to the forum.Thank you for hosting as well and to all the judges! You did a great job as a first time host!
You, David, Magic Feather, and now Pi all first time hosts doing well!
RMichael21
Well-Known Member
Congrats @FigmentPigments !!!!