I think a big problem for Disney, Pixar, and North American animation studios in general is that science fiction had been pretty well-covered by live-action filmmakers (and animators elsewhere, such as in France and most famously Japan) well before they got into the genre. Wall-E was the only film I can think of offhand that feels like something that hadn't already been done better in live-action. It's like how there have been few attempts at "high fantasy" animated features, as opposed to lower-stakes fairy tale-style fantasies, in the U.S. that did well; they couldn't keep pace with what live-action filmmakers had already accomplished. If anything I think a lot of sci-fi/high fantasy fans think animation is a step down, which isn't fair, but somewhat understandable. And Elio just reminds me so much of the kind of movies we got so many of via Amblin and Amblin-wannabes in the 1980s. What exactly is Pixar bringing to the table here to make it feel fresh? It's not a distinctive setting (like Lilo & Stitch had with Hawaii), or an unconventional protagonist(s) (like the senior citizens in Cocoon), so...We’ll see, I’m certainly not cheering against it. I felt way worse about Strange World going into it, but the company has a really bad history with animated sci fi.
Last edited: