Disneyland does this in several areas actually. Dumbo is represented by two rides right next to each other; Dumbo The Flying Elephant and Casey Jr. Circus Train, with Dumbo characters and music and theme elements recreated in both adjacent attractions.
Then there's the Alice In Wonderland dark ride that sits right next to the Mad Tea Party teacups, with the Mad Hatter hat shop wedged alongside the two Alice themed attractions. Tony Baxter has called this corner of Fantasyland an "Alice Miniland".
Pirate's Lair on Tom Sawyer Island references Pirates of the Caribbean across the way, with the Jack Sparrow stunt show firing cannons at and making use of the passing Sailing Ship Columbia. Etc., etc.
It's generally thought that sort of thing brings a richness of experiences to a park visit, and adds depth and interest to niches and corners of the park. It works very well at Disneyland at least.
Caveat accepted. :lol:
However, it's exactly this sort of thing that makes Disneyland and Magic Kingdom feel and act so differently. It wouldn't be a bad thing if they started doing this at Magic Kingdom.
I agree, TP2000! That's why I've always preferred the Disneyland Fantasyland! Instead of
Alice In Wonderland just being represented by the Teacups, which is just one very specific scene in the movie, DL also has the darkride which covers the entire scope of the movie - adding characters, settings, story, and musical elements from the film not found in the Teacups! This adds those layers of richness that you were referring to and gives a more "complete" Alice experience.
The same is true for
Dumbo, being represented not just by his own signature ride, but by the charming Casey Junior Circus Train attraction, and the Casey Junior theme song, as well!
Another good example is
Pinocchio. The Villiage Haus restaurant in the MK is very charming, and I love the way it tells the story of Pinocchio via the illustrations on the wall - but this is no match for the wonderful Pinocchio's Daring Journey dark ride, that DL has in ADDITION to the Village Haus restaurant!
As far as
Snow White in the MK, I am going to take a wait-and-see approach about this rumored Dwarfs Mine coaster, especially since we don't have official confirmation yet that the Snow White dark ride is closing.
Maybe it will be a coaster/dark ride "hybrid", that really does tell the story of Snow White as good as the dark ride, and would make the dark ride redundant.
On the other hand, if it just focuses on the Dwarfs and their Mine - one SPECIFIC aspect of the Snow White story just as the Teacups are just one specific aspect of Alice - then in that scenario I feel that they should also keep the Snow White darkride, just as DL builds that rich layer of theming by having more than one attraction or location tell the story of their classic films.
PS. I think one example of rich, multiple layers of theming that works well in the MK Fantasyland is
Cinderella. The Cinderella Castle is named for her, and the beautiful tile mosaic murals tell her story. This theme is extended to the nearby Cinderella Wishing Well and Cinderella Fountain. The fountain shows Cinderella in her "scullery maid" clothes, in a pose showing kindness to her animal friends. When viewed at just the right angle, a crown in the background fits her head. To me this statue represents that the qualities and beauty that make Cinderella a "princess" come from within.
The Cinderella motif culminates with her Carousel, in which 18 illustrations on the top of the Carousel tell her story as the ride turns.