WDW Resort Battles: Deluxe resort- Final

[WDWmazprty]

Continuing our resort battles, here's a recap:

Value resorts- Pop Century Resort

Moderate resorts- Port Orleans French Quarter

Now, the two finalists in the Deluxe resort battle are the Polynesian and Beach Club Resorts

The first one to get (15) votes in their battle will win that battle and move on in the tournament. Of course feel free to add any additional comments as well.

Here is the battle:


Polynesian vs. Beach Club

 

[DisneyMusician2]

Wow...this one is unbelievable tough. I think these are so great but have such different plusses in their columns.

Just for the accessibility to Epcot and the World Showcase and the best pool ever, I'll have to give it to Beach Club.

But the Poly is also an awesome experience...

 

[DisneyPrincess5]

Poly!!!

 

[captainkidd]

I'm voting for the Poly as it's rooms are larger, theme is better, food is better, transportation is better, and location rules.

However, I wish Wilderness Lodge had made the cut.

 

[wvdisneyfamily]

I'm voting for the Poly as it's rooms are larger, theme is better, food is better, transportation is better, and location rules.

However, I wish Wilderness Lodge had made the cut.

Ditto. I'm surprised at these results.

 

[WDWmazprty]

I'm voting for the Poly as it's rooms are larger, theme is better, food is better, transportation is better, and location rules.

However, I wish Wilderness Lodge had made the cut.

Ditto. I'm surprised at these results.

Tell me about it!

 

[WDWmazprty]

The Poly is out in front so far.

 

[bgraham34]

I'm voting for the Poly as it's rooms are larger, theme is better, food is better, transportation is better, and location rules.

However, I wish Wilderness Lodge had made the cut.

Agreed, Wilderness Lodge is the Best...

 

[WDWmazprty]

Almost there, just a few more votes.

 

[Splashman]

Polynesian

 

[captainkidd]

No offense to the OP, it's a fun idea, but why the first to 15 votes? To be honest, that really doesn't tell anything, other than who happens to ne online at a given time. On the previous poll, both Poly and WL are now tied with 20 votes.

The best way to do a poll like this is to simply list every resort, or at least each resort in a specific category, leave the poll open for a week, and see who comes out on top.

:shrug:

 

[WDWmazprty]

No offense to the OP, it's a fun idea, but why the first to 15 votes? To be honest, that really doesn't tell anything, other than who happens to ne online at a given time. On the previous poll, both Poly and WL are now tied with 20 votes.

The best way to do a poll like this is to simply list every resort, or at least each resort in a specific category, leave the poll open for a week, and see who comes out on top.

:shrug:

I get you, but I've done that before and the longer you leave it up, it'll keep changing; it'll never really tell you what the REAL concensus is.

I didnt want the contests to take forever, plus its just for fun. Plus, I think the way the other contests hosts (Densetigerwave and Splashman) have done is somewhet similar.

I figure, 15 is a good number. The first ones to get in and vote are the ones that count. Of course, you have to vote .

But maybe for the next battles I'll make it the first 20 or 25 votes. Thanks!

 

[Lucky]

15-10 is a nice football-like final score.

 

[WDWmazprty]

Ok, we have a winner! Poly defeats Beach Club 15-10.

We will now move on to the Deluxe Villas.