From the perspective of someone who has been to WDW probably 40+ times, has family in Orlando, and is VERY nostalgic for the feelings WDW gives...
We’re going to have to wildly disagree.
You can like whatever you want for various reasons, but there are a ton of things you have to overlook to reach that conclusion.
There are double the amount of rides at Disneyland Park versus Magic Kingdom, and multiple headliners unlike Magic Kingdom’s 1, Splash Mountain, and triple the amount of small-scale dark rides. Basically, all the rides there have also
actually been updated.
Magic Kingdom
is stuck in the 70s. I took friends to WDW last summer and it was fascinating hearing their perspectives on the parks making a ton of things more obvious than otherwise would be.
And don't get me wrong, I still like Magic Kingdom, but there are a ton of issues with it, most notably the overcrowding that massively inflates queue times. Maybe Disneyland "feels" more crowded to you, but outside of fireworks, there is never gridlock anywhere.
The queues on the other hand suggest Magic Kingdom is facing this issue in a much larger way.
Many equivalents that are found on both coasts are significantly better at DL: Pirates, Autopia, the list goes on. The only ride definitely better at MK
was Splash. The equivalent rides Orlando has that are marginally improved just haven’t received updates.
The quick-service restaurants are leagues better at DL, like, it’s in another stratosphere. The only park in Orlando that can compete on that front is Animal Kingdom.
The table-service restaurants DL has are more affordable and not a pre-fixe menu. Most of the ones at MK are weak anyway: Blue Bayou’s new menu puts anything at MK to shame.
The service is better with Cast Members seemingly SO proud of their park. I just love striking up a conversation with so many people, there’s this respect for theme parks and attention to detail on a level I generally only find in Tokyo. WDW has great CMs, don’t get me wrong, but it’s not as consistent as DL. It most definitely helps to pool from a larger metro area and having Hollywood so close by. SoCal culture is also just more laid-back than Florida’s locals and especially the tourists since locals are only a
tiny slice of WDW.
The crowds are nicer since they’re not touristy that feel like they have to do everything. It’s the difference between going to a tourist spot in Rome, Italy versus a local spot.
It’s cheaper to visit for the same amount of days, and with walking distance hotels for under $150 a night, it’s night and day a better value than WDW. Like we're talking thousands for a 5-day trip if someone wants to stay close to the parks.
Disneyland typically has
much longer park hours.
Disneyland has not one but TWO night shows: Fantasmic! and a fireworks show. I’d take Happily Over After over the still excellent Wondrous Journeys, but man, Fantasmic! is elite, and breathtaking the way it comes out of nowhere… while also being better than its Hollywood Studios counterpart. It’s also not as much of a chore to get to, and in an entirely separate park.
My biggest problem with MK is that it has more attendance than DL even though many things at Disneyland Park are found at other Walt Disney World parks instead of MK making it spread thin for the crowds it gets.
Disneyland actually has to invest in seasonal entertainment, unlike WDW, with real ride overlays.
Fewer bathrooms sure, but I actually never had an issue waiting even though I went during the peak Spring Break crowds (and women didn't seem to have a problem either outside of post-fireworks). As for the walkways, Project Star Dust massively improved the guest experience in subtle ways. They even converted gift shops to rest areas!
The weather is just night and day better in SoCal than in Orlando, which is far too hot and humid for a theme park 4 months out of the year.
I also love that there are more walk-around characters at Disneyland versus just meet-and-greets at WDW, which means more lines I have to wait in and ruin the spontaneity of a good character interaction.
There’s this quaintness in design and an animator’s touch MK just lacks. There’s also New Orleans Square which is the best-themed land out of either park, and DL has Galaxy’s Edge
and Toontown on top of all the things MK has (if you swap NOS for LS).
The wait times are far less overall since MK has more attendance than DL but half the rides.
You know MK has a problem when Peter Pan’s Flight and Jungle Cruise like to stay at 90+ minutes; that’s why they’re doing the Beyond Big Thunder expansion because the line-up is
severely lacking for the attendance making the guest experience worse.
Actually, Disneyland is straight-up like if Hollywood Studios (Galaxy's Edge, Mickey, Star Tours, and Fantasmic!) were thrown into MK, and then still has even more to do (Indy, Fantasyland dark rides, etc.).
I like the random diversions DL has like the Explorer Canoes. The only thing I really would like at DL is the Peoplemover. The Country Bears and Carousel of Progress are so painfully outdated that I would gladly take DL’s updated Fantasyland dark rides over them given the choice. Or Indiana Jones Adventure, Runaway Railway, or Rise of the Resistance. The only thing really lacking from DL is the Hall of Presidents as Lincoln just doesn’t compare, but there’s also a Lion King show at Disneyland. MK doesn’t have a show like that at all.
TRON has the same issues Seven Dwarfs Mine Train has: it’s short. It’s not a headliner. It will have 2+ hours waits.
Maybe you like different things in a theme park, sure, there’s more placement for something like the Tiki Room having a grander lead-up, but for me personally, I could care less about that if it’s still themed well and there’s more to do, which there is.
I’d put DisneySea as the best theme park in the world, and Disneyland Park as the second, or best if you emphasize its ride line-up. MK just lacks on all the fronts mentioned.
For reference
Disneyland Park
Headliners
- Rise of the Resistance (new)
- Indiana Jones Adventure (updated)
- Pirates of the Caribbean (a huge step up over Orlando's)
E/D-Tickets
- Runaway Railway (new)
- Big Thunder Mountain Railroad (updated)
- Space Mountain (updated)
- Tiana’s Bayou Adventure (probably)
- Jungle Cruise (updated)
- Haunted Mansion (updated)
- Star Tours (updated)
- Smuggler’s Run (new)
- Buzz (updated)
- Submarine Voyage (updated)
- Autopia (updated. I couldn’t believe how much better it was… it feels like a D-ticket)
Magic Kingdom Park
Headliners
- Tiana’s Bayou Adventure (probably)
E/D-Tickets
- Space Mountain (outdated)
- TRON (new, I rode it in Shanghai, so basing this off of that)
- Big Thunder Mountain Railroad (outdated)
- Jungle Cruise (updated)
- Haunted Mansion (updated)
- Pirates of the Caribbean
- Seven Dwarfs Mine Train (new)
- Buzz (outdated)
That’s not even factoring in Alice in Wonderland (updated), Snow White’s Enchanted Wish (updated), Pinocchio’s Daring Journey, Mr. Toad’s Wild Ride, and Roger Rabbit’s Cartoon Spin that MK just doesn’t have, and an actually updated
Peter Pan’s Flight (that mind you, rarely gets above 45 minutes) versus the one at MK, that while longer, has curtains as walls instead of fiber optics and laughably bad audio…
And of course, things that aren’t measured in just rides like I already mentioned: lower wait times, better food overall, kinder crowds, longer hours.
Walt Disney World is unquestionably the more impressive resort than Disneyland Resort, but when comparing Disneyland Park to Magic Kingdom, there's absolutely no contest.