Vote! Fireworks Contest (Final Poll)

[Monorail]

Is it worth having a confrontation over?

I think it's worth having the discussion. I'm pretty sure everyone's been polite about it so far. It'd be nice if we could just rely on everyone following their conscience but, unfortunately, not everyone's conscience is an exceptional guide.

 

[Erika]

I think it's worth having the discussion. I'm pretty sure everyone's been polite about it so far. It'd be nice if we could just rely on everyone following their conscience but, unfortunately, not everyone's conscience is an exceptional guide.

True, still, I think we should hit the brakes until allabtbrdway is able to respond. Her profile says she'll be back later this week.

 

[DDuckFan130]

True, still, I think we should hit the brakes until allabtbrdway is able to respond. Her profile says she'll be back later this week.

Oh la la!

:lookaroun

Thanks Erika!

 

[kevlightyear]

I don't know if someone cheated or not but if someone does I say just let their conscience be their guide. Is it worth having a confrontation over? If you are right and they did cheat, what are you going to do, have them banned from the boards? Harass and embarrass them? I just see it coming to a very uncomfortable ending for everyone, the original poster and everyone else who comments or questions about it. I just don’t think it is worth all that.

I wasn't trying to cause trouble. It doesn't really matter to me what the outcome is. I thought it was photoshopped, so I didn't vote for it. In fact, it was so unbelieveable to me, that I was surprised it had won. It's not gonna change my life, and I hope I haven't insulted anyone. I'm not screaming insurgency, just commenting.

 

[mrtoad]

I wasn't trying to cause trouble. It doesn't really matter to me what the outcome is. I thought it was photoshopped, so I didn't vote for it. In fact, it was so unbelieveable to me, that I was surprised it had won. It's not gonna change my life, and I hope I haven't insulted anyone. I'm not screaming insurgency, just commenting.

I was not pointing fingers and hope it did not come out that way. I was just saying that I think that in the end it is just going to make a very uncomfortable situation. Either someone did cheat and that is hanging over their head for everyone to see or they didn't and it would be hanging over everyone else for asking if they did.

Anyway, I was not pointing fingers at you or anyone else. Sorry if it came out that way.

 

[wannab@dis]

I was not pointing fingers and hope it did not come out that way. I was just saying that I think that in the end it is just going to make a very uncomfortable situation. Either someone did cheat and that is hanging over their head for everyone to see or they didn't and it would be hanging over everyone else for asking if they did.

Anyway, I was not pointing fingers at you or anyone else. Sorry if it came out that way.

I'll be the first to recant, apologize and delete my post if the picture is legit! If it's not legit, it can be removed, a new poll taken and end of story. Nothing needs to get "uncomfortable". :wave:

 

[Chape19714]

I've been sorta avoiding this, but I feel something must be said. There is definately something off in this photo. In addition to wdwscottyboy's photo researching, I would like to point out that all the Shaped Fireworks (hearts) are launched from behind the castle, outside of the railroad. This photo shows heart fireworks above adventureland, where there are no heart fireworks set off. It's a great photo, but I too question it. I've seen Wishes about 35+times now in it's still retively new run, and have never seen hearts being set off at the same time as low-levels.

Just my .02.

 

[kevlightyear]

Anyway, I was not pointing fingers at you or anyone else. Sorry if it came out that way.

Not at all. :wave:
I just wasn't expecting it to be such a big deal.

 

[mrtoad]

Not at all. :wave:
I just wasn't expecting it to be such a big deal.

Cool.

 

[WDWScottieBoy]

We shall all just sit back and wait for allabrt to come and defend themselves. Until then, congrats for having the winning photo!

 

[nibblesandbits]

Hi everybody!!!

I am back from beautiful Jamaica! I had a wonderful wedding...exactly what I always wanted. On the beach and everything! :sohappy:

I just wanted to address something really quickly...as I noticed the problems going on in this thread while I was away.

I would like to ask for people not to call others out publically in the thread. If you have a problem or a concern with one of the posts or pictures, I would appreciate it if you would PM me about them. That way I can look into it because I don't to embarrass people. I don't think that this is too much to ask. Thank you! :wave:

 

[kevlightyear]

Hi everybody!!!

I am back from beautiful Jamaica! I had a wonderful wedding...exactly what I always wanted. On the beach and everything! :sohappy:

I just wanted to address something really quickly...as I noticed the problems going on in this thread while I was away.

I would like to ask for people not to call others out publically in the thread. If you have a problem or a concern with one of the posts or pictures, I would appreciate it if you would PM me about them. That way I can look into it because I don't to embarrass people. I don't think that this is too much to ask. Thank you! :wave:

Not at all. I'm sorry it got so out of hand. As I said, I debated posting in the first place. We'll all try and PM you first in the future.

Anyway, CONGRATULATIONS!!

 

[nibblesandbits]

Not at all. I'm sorry it got so out of hand. As I said, I debated posting in the first place. We'll all try and PM you first in the future.

Anyway, CONGRATULATIONS!!

Trust me...it didn't get as out of hand as I had feared! I've seen a lot worse fights in these photography threads!

Not a problem though...I just wanted to deal with the problems in a little better way.

And thanks for the congratulations! (If anyone is interested, there will be a trip report posted in chit chat in the next few days! I promise...no honeymoon stuff will be included! :lol: :lookaroun )