I do not consider myself wearing rose color glasses at all. It's about the value we get for our money and how we spend our vacation time, both limited commodities. We have done WDW and a number of other vacations and we keep returning to WDW as we find it to be what we enjoy the most. To the point where we bought into it long term via DVC this year. Although I will sat DCL is a awesome second choice
The crowds at WDW are a fact of life at this point, nothing to be done to keep the folks from coming to WDW from across the world so trying to expand the parks (i.e. Avatar) or move the crowds smarter (i.e. FP+) is the way to go IMO. I wish as much as the next guy for a 5th gate, I hope to have one someday. But it not being there now is not going to keep me from enjoying the parks and all they have to offer right now.
I am not worried about margins, I do that at work. Not going to do it on vacation. The folks at Disney know a thing or two about running the parks and to me they are doing fine. They get paid to worry about margins at WDW, not me
Beside they have so much more information than any of us regarding their business model and numbers that it's silly to try and debate it on the internet IMO. I know people like too and that's fine but it is not something I want to do.
I look at WDW at a simple choice, do I like what I get in return for my money or not? If yes then I go, if no then I don't. At this point we certainly do, and we feel like that will continue thus the DVC purchase. If at some point we do not then we will sell the DVC and move on to something else. Vacations are relaxing, not stressful so I have little tolerance for taking vacations that stress me out. One of the reason I like going to WDW is that it can be all inclusive, or at least very much so. Room, tickets and dinning all paid for in advance. With the FP+ and MBs even more so IMO. Just arrive and spend a week kicking around doing what we want to do in a place that makes us smile, a lot....
That is good stuff to us