Tutto Italia vs Coral Reef

[lovepooh]

Hi All-

We are going to be attending CP and we have a choice of booking the Tutto or the Coral Reef. We have eaten and the Coral Reef before its pretty good, um service not so much. But never been to the tutto and i am curious if anyone thinks the tutto would be the better bet.

Thanks for all advice!:xmas:

 

[DisneyPrincess5]

If you've been to Coral Reef but never been to Tutto, try there!
My mother eats there on every one of her trips and loves it.
Plus, if by CP you mean Candlelight Processional, at Tutto you'll be closer to it.

Have a great trip!

 

[reptar77]

Tutto is good but expensive. We also like the Coral Reef, that's a tough one. I guess it comes down to what you want to eat.

 

[IMA*WDW*ADDICT]

I would go to Tutto ... just don't expect american type Italian... (my husband was and was caught off guard!)
The restaurant is absolutely beautiful and the food it really good! I have bene to both and I am not impress with Coral Reef... so I would definitely say try out Tutto!

 

[lovepooh]

We have been to the coral reef 2x. The first time was great but we were one of the last ressies that night and felt rushed. The second time the food was ok...

But those were our choices for the CP ... Would you compare the Tutto to any other kind of italian resturant???

Thanks for all advice:xmas:

 

[Tiggerish]

Wow. Two completely different cuisines. Both good.

If you've never tried Tutto, go for it. It is expensive, though.

I brought Italians (okay, Bronx Italians, but they think they are more genuine than Italians from Italy) and they enjoyed the heck out of Tutto.
Especially the handsome waitstaff.

 

[PotteryGal]

If you're comparing the service, Tutto's was much better for us. Very attentive, and very efficient. Coral Reef was super slow, although the food was okay. I definitely want to go back to Tutto again.

 

[meganw1985]

We ate at Coral Reef in April. Second time there. I remember the food being good, and the lobster bisque is delicious. But really the draw to us is the atmosphere. We sat so far away from the tank this time though which kind of stunk. We had so many other much better meals on our trip it gets a moderate stamp of approval from me. Never been to Tutto Italia, have wanted to try, but I eat Italian at home all the time...

 

[blackthidot]

I'm doing both so Ill let you know when I get back!

 

[thegreenfairy]

It could have just been a poor day when I was there, but the food at Coral Reef was hands down the WORST I have ever had at Disney. The service was not so great either....but they were very sweet about it being my honeymoon trip and brought us out special menus and champagne and strawberries. The atmosphere is nice, but only if you are right by the tanks IMHO.

 

[blackthidot]

It could have just been a poor day when I was there, but the food at Coral Reef was hands down the WORST I have ever had at Disney. The service was not so great either....but they were very sweet about it being my honeymoon trip and brought us out special menus and champagne and strawberries. The atmosphere is nice, but only if you are right by the tanks IMHO.

Ive eaten at Coral Reef now 4 times...Will be going again for the 5th time.


The food has always been great for me. Small portions but its always been good. I agree about the tank...if youre not near it it will defiantly take a lot of excitement out of your experience!