Put me in the same boat. I own at AKL (and SSR and VWL) but am staying at BLT next week because I'm taking my parents. Its just way easier on the monorail. AKL is still my favorite though.
@Fox&Hound if you haven't stayed there, give it a go. It's phenomenal. Kidani splash area is fantastic if you have littles, and outside of Grand Floridian- there isn't a better restaurant selection out there (Id rank GF and AKL 1A and 1B).
Its also the only resort that has several activities to do for free. Culinary tours, face painting, story telling, music classes, etc. For me, when I got DVC, I started slowing down a little more knowing I have another 50 yrs of WDW
So thats why I prefer AKL when its just us. I hang a little more and don't mind the bus ride as much.
Although BCV is a close 2nd favorite. That pool... Beaches and cream.... heaven.