what about all the people that dont get there selection and spend 3 months checking the app every day? is that fun?
Every system has winners and losers. You can't have everyone 'win' by being able to go on all the best rides with relatively little to no wait unless there are much fewer people than the park has capacity for -- which rarely happens (or you pay extra for it).
When you have crowds and some rides much more popular than others (and some of those popular ones with a low capacity), then you're going to get lines. and then some people have to wait 40, 60, 90, or 120 minutes.
With no FPs at all, winners are rope droppers... who show up before all the other rope droppers. Then it becomes a game of wondering if you need to show up 30, or 60, or 90 minutes before rope drop to ride that brand new E-Ticket. Then, with a large rope-dropping crowd, after they all get to ride their first choice ride with little wait, the park is now crowded and their next E-Ticket choice already has a 90 minute wait.
With the paper FPs, winners were the rope droppers who got on their first ride quickly, and then knew to quickly sprint to the next several rides. People who showed up mid-morning or later? Losers in that game.
With FP+, winners are long term planners. Losers are those who don't. But even then, plenty of E-Ticket rides can be found up until days before you arrive. With FP+, the winners don't have to rope-drop and make the morning rush a huge rush. They don't have to sprint across the park. People who want to ride the big E-Ticket can find a scheduled time often later in the day... maybe not the time they wanted, but it beats waiting in line for 90 minutes.
Also, when you pass a park's tipping point, that is, when there is more people than all the rides can accommodate, you get a back-up of the queues under any system... FP or no FP. Surpassed capacity is surpassed. Lines back up. MK is often passing it's tipping point daily... sometimes for part of the day, sometimes for the whole day. And FP can't be blamed for that. What is to blame is the lack of MK's capacity to handle that many people and the lack of the drawing power of the other 3 parks (which have a lower tipping point, so, they can only help so much).
WDW attendance over all is increasing at a faster rate than attraction capacity. You don't need FP in the equation to predict what that means.
Last edited: