Thank you so much for this description. Not surprisingly, it worries me a great deal by seeming to reinforce a lot of my fears for the attraction and concerns about Disneys approach generally.
1) an obsessive fidelity to the details of an IP while ignoring its essence and the requirements of the dark ride medium. The finale seems to focus on all the least interesting characters from the film - who cares about Naveen’s relatives? - which only emphasizes that the genuinely interesting figures (Ray, Facilier, the frog prince and princess) are absent. We’ve known about that decision for a long time, of course, but the logical way forward would have been to fill the scene with colorful critters created to suit the ride, not populate the tableau with bland extras from the film. Honestly, this scene seems to be keeping the worst elements of a book report ride. That leads us to the related issue of
1b) Louis. The ride seems to be heavily reliant on the most generic major character from the film, an animal sidekick that seemed churned out because that’s what Disney does. Ray was a distinct personality with an arc, pathos, and a unique presence - Louis seemed to exist for no narrative reason other then that Ray was going to die and the movie needed a backup. At least Louis will be a distinctive figure, however, and not another
2) Humanoid AA. This is less an issue here then in RotR because the characters will be cartoonish, but Disneys reliance on human AAs continues to be frustrating. Splash was special in large part because it was a feast of unique AAs, creatures of every size and shape that couldn’t be reproduced by humans in costumes. That’s one of the advantages of using AAs! Of course, the greatest dark ride of all time, Pirates, is full of (caricatured) AAs, but it avoids a feeling of banality by not falling into the trap of the
3) “face and wave.” The push to “put guests in the story” means that, rather then forming interesting or comical scenes, modern Disney AAs largely just look and wave at guests, often while singing. It’s very boring. This new finale seems reminiscent of the last scene of Frozen, in which the characters stand there, staring at us and singing.
An attraction can withstand one of these issues and still be great. All three together, however, are an extreme liability.