I think we should just chalk this up to cultural differences between busy New York and beachy SoCal.
This is what I just found. As I suspected from my memory and Lived Experiences
, printed Allergy Menus and formalized options didn't arrive at Disneyland until the mid 2010's.
The first published Allergy Menu options arrived at Disney World in
September, 2014, and they were for Gluten Free options. It was rolled out as a "pilot program" at select table service restaurants.
Then in
April, 2015 the pilot program led to the first official Allergy Menus were offered at Disney World
and Disneyland. In 2015 they expanded the menu options to five different allergies. Prior to this, the suggestion on the Disneyland website for those with food allergies was to
"Ask to speak with a Chef about meal options" at your dining location.
(Try that at the Tomorrowland Terrace window on a busy Saturday at Noon.)
Allergy-friendly menus are currently being tested at select Disney World restaurants.
www.disneyfoodblog.com