Another vote for Cape May Cafe from me.
We've done the following, and I offer our weighted family average score:
Boma (dinner twice) - Grade B. great atmosphere. Some great food, some less than great. Hit and miss (mostly miss) service.
Chef Mickey's (dinner twice) - Grade C for food. Grade A minus for fun/atmosphere
Crystal Palace (breakfast) - Grade B+ - Brekkie is brekkie. Character interaction was great
Biergarten (dinner) - Grade A minus - Great food. We arrived at the end of one show, and the next started just as we were leaving, so that was a bit of a let down. You potentially sit with strangers, but the family we sat with was lovely.
Mickey's Backyard Barbeque - Grade B minus - My kids were a little old for the show. The food didn't warrant 2 TS credits per person. And dang, it was HOT in there at the end of August.
Cape May Cafe (breakfast) - Grade A+ - No complaints. Great food. Great service. Great atmosphere.
Relaxed, unhurried meal, with plenty of character interaction.
Cape May Cafe (dinner twice) - Grade A from all (A+ from hubby who likes clams). Good food selection. Less hectic than Chef Mickey's due to lack of characters.
1900 Park Fare (breakfast) - Grade B minus. Again Breakfast is breafast, hard to screw up, but something was just "off". I wasn't crazy about the table set up, but I'm not sure if that's what dropped the grade for us. Character interaction was rushed.
Hollywood & Vine (dinner) - Grade A minus. I don't get the hate for this place. Up until we discovered Cape May, this was food-wise, our favourite buffet. No characters at dinner.