I feel that you could make a case for just about any resort that isn't value tier (although Contemporary, however iconic it is from the exterior, is not to my taste) over there. They're all impressive in their own way. Grand Californian is the only one at DLR that approaches or matches the feel of the resorts at WDW, though I think there are some nice aspects of the Disneyland Hotel as well.
If money was no object, my choice would be Animal Kingdom Lodge, but there are plenty of resorts there that I haven't explored. I was very pleasantly surprised by Coronado Springs in October (and the bar at the top of their new tower has a spectacular view of much of the resort). Of the ones I haven't explored yet, I'd most like to visit Caribbean Beach, Port Orleans, and Wilderness Lodge.
Polynesian seems to match the vibe that I want on a vacation and i love Hawaiian food. It also has great transportation to MK and Epcot(?) I believe?
I like that Beach Club is located right next to two of the 4 parks but I’m not as drawn to the theme/aesthetic. I eliminated Yacht Club and Boardwalk as I feel Beach Club Is the best of the 3 for me.
The Contemporary, although I enjoy the Mid Century Modern aesthetic and the Iconic A frame with the monorail going through it, isn’t really the vibe I want to go all in on for a 9 day vacation. Especially the first trip. The food options sound pretty good though.
I love the look of Port Orleans but I feel that it’s kind of in “No Man’s Land” meaning you re not splurging and staying in a Deluxe but also not saving the money you would be at a value - a couple of which have much better transpo options like Pop Century and Art of Animation.
Wilderness Lodge - I’ve been to Yosemite and have stayed at The Grand Californian a couple times which I feel is similar enough so it’s not as high on my list
Grand Floridian - Looks nice but I have 2 young kids so it doesn’t seem like the right choice.
Animal Kingdom Lodge - Doesn’t seem like the place you stay at on your first trip. Far away from everything and only buses for transportation.
We decided that we re going to splurge on our first WDW trip and do like a 10 day stay at a Deluxe Resort. I could totally see me coming back thinking it’s not worth the money and go with a value resort the second trip, if there is one. I see myself wanting to go to the parks a lot (which drastically lowers the value of a Deluxe Resort) but with a longer stay we could bake in 3 down days and with the kids we’ll probably need it. We were going to to go to WDW for my wife’s best friends wedding next January which they almost booked but plans changed and they are now getting married in California. Once again the WDW Gods have not shined on me. So now we re thinking of going next Spring or possibly as late as when our youngest turns 4 which wouldn’t be until Fall 2024. If I go next year they will be 7 and 2 years old. I think waiting til they re 9 and 4 probably makes more sense and will make for a better trip. At a certain point though you just get tired of waiting for the perfect time.
Last edited: