The Imagineer-- FINALS-Project 8

MaterA113

New Member
Original Poster
I have Disneyson's stuff, so im waiting on KingMIckey's stuff...

IF he doesnt send me the stuff by the time i get hom from WDW (im heading there right now) tonight, i will just make the decision and post Disneyson and I's stuff.
 

MaterA113

New Member
Original Poster
Sorry once agian for the delay, BUT we have a tie, SO we need YOU all the Public of WDWMagic to vote, check out the poll of The Imagineer- Finale Public Vote to choose who you thnk should win.
 

MaterA113

New Member
Original Poster
NOTE: We really didn’t have a tie, it was just since we didn’t have a third judge, I wanted it to seem fair, and not just two. Just letting you all know. And the people voted for JASONFLZ.
MaterA113’s Comments
--addition of YOUR new Restaurants (TS and ODV)
Jasonflz- I thought it was ok, I didn’t see anything BIG that changed, but ok.
Bam- Since you didn’t have an ODV it was kind of hard, I know, but it was good. Except it was supposed to tie into your Table Service, BUT other than that, I really liked the ODV idea. Liked the restaurant, and you used our comments well.
--addition of YOUR new parade with updates for a 40th Anniversary Overlay
Jasonflz- I thought the parade with having the people carrying the different banners was a bit extreme, and kind of over kill, but I liked how you used our comments from the. I still think the sense of chorological events is not correct, as you have in the middle, where it is only the second movie, not farther down the line. Characters should say more than “hi” on the floats.
Bam-The parade was ok, it is similar to Jasonflz’s but that is not your fault. I don’t have that much to say, as you did the same on the previous parade project. You used our comments a little bit.
--ONE NEW LAND (either replacing Toontown, or going outside berm behind Fantasyland)
****WITH at least 3 attractions AND TWO of them must be of your OWN creation and at least ONE of them has to be an E-Ticket,
****NEED 1 shop and
****an ORIGINAL restaurant
Jasonflz- I feel a bit iffy about the land; it seems too similar to Adventureland. Your E-ticket does seem too similar to the E- ticket in Adventureland that you made. I LOVED your restaurant idea. Overall ok.
Bam- I don’t know how I feel about this. Because im not a Phineas and Ferb fan, so im trying not to get that to cloud my judgment, but it is ok. I think having a land focusing on ONE franchise is a problem, as it is almost permanent, and if it begins to tank, the land is there, and most of the time they spent MILLIONS of dollars on it. I like the restaurant and the attractions. And I don’t get the restaurant, maybe its because im not a P&F fan, but I don’t know.
--update or refurb to ONE attraction in each main land (Adventureland, Frontierland, Tomorrowland, and Fantasyland, NO USE of PIRATE or SPACE MOUNTAIN though)
Jasonflz- I like the Adventureland Tiki Room refurbishment. Frontierland idea was good, it connected the land more than just having Thunder Mountain a far way from the town. I really enjoyed your Tomorrowland idea, BUT I don’t know what to do, because the “refurbishment” seems like a NEW ATTRACTION, but I really do like the idea. The Fantasyland refurbishment, by far, in my opinion was the least likeable of your refurbishments, they seemed boring and kind of ok, that is what they do in a normal refurbishment. Overall I enjoyed your refurbishments.
Bam- I like the Country Bear refurb, it is needed. The Philharmagic refurb I don’t really like. They have TOO similar movies and too close together in release. I feel that it is needed that they be different. And the Haunted Mansion doesn’t fit, especially with the Mansion literally around the corner. The TTA refurb was ok, but I think the vehicles shouldn’t have ceilings on them, just my opinion. And finally, I liked your refurbishment on the Jungle Cruise. Like the new “effects”, that is the kind of refurb I was talking about.

--Castle Decor for 40th
Jasonflz- The castle décor was a bit mediocre, it was ok, but it wasn’t WOW! It seemed similar to the 50th Anniversary. It was just OK.
Bam- I like the idea, but I don’t see it turning out good, I do like your drawing though. It seems TOO similar to What will you celebrate? And in real life I feel the castle will look weird with Balloons on its spires.
--ONE new attraction in EACH Fantasyland AND Adventureland
--ONE new attraction in Frontierland OR Tomorrowland
--ONE of those 3 attractions (above) MUST be a E/D Ticket

Jasonflz- I really liked the Adventureland idea, it seemed very similar to Jungle Expedition, that was suppose to take Jungle Cruise’s place in DLP, but it was different. The Fantasyland attraction was ok, kind of TOO similar to Peter Pans Flight. The Frontierland attraction was my favorite of yours, the story was GREAT and helped connect Frontierland together.
Bam- Swingin Trees is good, I like the tie in to Tarzan, also Adventureland is in need for an E-Ticket. Tomorrowland idea is good, but again, another stitch ride. I LOVE STITCH, but I feel that he IS overdone. I like the Fantasyland attraction, BUT it is TOO new for an attraction, and I feel that you did A LOT from the beginning of the movie, but didn’t do that much of second half. I feel with a few more scenes, it would be a great attraction. I also like the layout pictures.


--ALL Refurbished, added, or changed attractions NEED descriptions, and at least 3 of them need SOME SORT OF VISUAL
Jasonflz- the Visuals were ok, but not as visual as I wanted, you kept showing logos, I wanted pics of ride vehicles or the rides. (But that is kind of my fault)
Bam- The pics and descriptions were all good, not too much, and good.

--E or D ticket needs a STORY BEHIND IT
Jasonflz- Stories were good.
Bam- (same as above)

--Redo Main Street Exposition hall with NEW walkthrough
Jasonflz- By far the Main Street expo hall walkthrough was just ok, it didn’t seem original, but it was ok.
Bam- Similar to jasons, but ok… TOO similar to most other walk through. I love Vinylmations, BUT they don’t connect to Disney Blueprints.

Disneyson 1’s Comments
--addition of YOUR new Restaurants (TS and ODV)
Jasonflz’s Skyway Diner & Snackport This isn’t what needed work, but I think that it was fine for what it was. I mean, it was nice but the menu COULD have been a bit more upscale for your dine-in and banners weren’t really necessary. The “theme” of both were great and fine for me.
Bamsk8er49’s Cosmic Ray’s Cuisine What an improvement! I love it when stuff like this happens! And you completely changed the ODV! I love the new stuff; you completely started from scratch! THIS is what I wanted to see; vast improvements and amazingness! Congrats!



--addition of YOUR new parade with updates for a 40th Anniversary Overlay
Jasonflz’s 40th Anniversary Special Well, the update was a bit of a quickie and the name was a bit weird, but nice nonetheless.
When you say “Tinkerbell” running around, I’m not sure if a costumed version of her would be appropriate, And the “forest” is a bit overkill for Neverland. It feels like Neverland & Bambi should come first with Chernabog kinda coming out weirdly at the end… so that was weird…
Wonderland and Pinnochio is a nice touch. I like it.
Kinda wondering how Dumbo would fly, would he be attached to the back?
Cinderella sounds gorgeous! She deserves something other than that omnipresent pumpkin…
Not sure how I feel about all animatronics on the float…It’s just a little vague.
I really wish that you developed the finale floats. It’s such a shame; I’d love to hear at least one version of the “changing” float. A change for the finale would have been great, too. The boat doesn’t work for me.
I was really expecting a show stop for this one! With the banner waiving and everything, I was getting excited. Oh well.
Bamsk8er49’s Animating the Years A complete turn-around. I can’t believe that this happened. You made great decisions and soon you made a fantastic parade
I can just imagine the Steamboat Willie float, it’s so good…
Nice, simple Snow White float
The Pinocchio float reminds me of the baking float in the Christmas Parade!
Did you mean Cinderella’s Carousel… or her coach? This one is confusing…
The Jungle Book idea is really vibrant. Great idea.
Aladdin sounds sooooo great.
Pocahantas and the finale… meh. Alright. It seems you have an obsession with Pocahantas, no? The pickaxe dancers sound great, though. And although a nice way to end, I can’t imagine the paper-float thing. Doesn’t make sense…

--ONE NEW LAND (either replacing Toontown, or going outside berm behind Fantasyland)

Jasonflz’s Treasureland: I like the idea of this land, but the “Giant Skull” is a bit of a hard pill to swallow. I just don’t feel the “immersive-ness” here. It’s a shame, your ride and attractions sound great! But I couldn’t help thinking of this giant skull that sits atop my hometown in Long Island’s old Haunted House with a giant skull atop it. If you re-work the exterior of the place with just a smidge more detail, that’d be wonderful.
Bamsk8er49’s Phineas & Ferb Land: Although I have serious issues with the name and the location and the topic, the rides seem fantastic and the atmosphere great! Might be hard to re-create a whole city as a land, though… and this might not last so long, considering Disney Channel things have relatively short lives. By the way, all of your drawings are fantastic!

****WITH at least 3 attractions AND TWO of them must be of your OWN creation and at least ONE of them has to be an E-Ticket,
Jasonflz’s Lost Treasure Although similar to Adventureland’s, your ride was very nice. I can see some ideas from Indiana Jones and The Mummy Coaster at IoA migrated here!
Jasonflz’s Treasure Hunters Eh. Could’ve used more story, but cute idea for those not tall enough to ride Lost Treasure!
Jasonflz’s Los Puertos Nice idea, but still wish there was a bit more detail!
Bamsk8er9’s Coolest Coaster Ever is a nice idea and a great tie-in to the land.
Bamsk8er49’s Carnival Is this a ride or what? It’s weird; I can’t imagine this to be a real show, but it’s a great tie-in to the land
Bamsk8er49’s Perry’s Grand Mission is probably the best ride in the land. Very good idea!

****NEED 1 shop and

Jasonflz All 3 shops are nice, esp. the onein the skull
Bamsk8er49 Shops are O.K., can’t imagine the googleplex as a shop…

****an ORIGINAL restaurant

Jasonflz’s Diamond This is the only “fantastic” thing in your land, but it’s really good. Nice idea that’s needed. Once again, food choices should be a little more varied, but all together a “cute” addition
Bamsk8er49 Paul Bunyan’s Uhh… why is this in Phineas & Ferb land…?

--update or refurb to ONE attraction in each main land (Adventureland, Frontierland, Tomorrowland, and Fantasyland, NO USE of PIRATE or SPACE MOUNTAIN though)

Jasonflz’s Tiki Room Refurb Everything sounds fantastic, especially the pre-show. I’d love to know whyat the rock did, though…
Jasonflz’s Big Thunder Refurb The ideas are the best you’ve had this whole project. A gem of an idea that should be realized.
Jasonflz’s Plectu’s Review This is also a wonderful idea that should be put into motion. Magical moments (such as characters talking to you) are what Disney is made of.
Jasonflz’s Peter Pan Refurb Although something besides lighting & paint would be nice, this is a much needed refurb that seems thoughtful.
Bamsk8er49’s Jungle Cruise Refurb A great idea for our JC to be separated from the rest! Very inspired.
Bamsker49’s TTA Cars Once again, great pics and a great idea
Bamsk8er49’s Philharmagic It’s pretty well done, but I think the Dr. Facillier & Haunted Mansion references are too “dark” and generally out of place in the show.
Bamsk8er49’s Country Bears That’s a wonderful idea, it really needs an upgrade

--Castle Decor for 40th

Jasonflz’s décor seems tasteful and nice, save for that giant sign. Can we omit it, please? The giant things on the castle never turn out well. The LEDs, though, are really nice touches.
Bamsk8er49’s décor is a thing that I really wanted to hate… but it wasn’t so bad… a nice new look.

--at least ONE ORIGINAL attraction to EACH of the 3 lands (Adventureland, Frontierland, and Fantasyland; NO WRE, Geyser Mtn)

--One of the NEW attractions from above MUST be an E OR D Ticket attraction

Jasonflz’s Jungle Trek I think we need a new rule next season: NO SHRUNKEN NED! Ha ha, no, but I never knew that he was so popular since, like, now. I like the idea of the jungle, but you kinda lost me at the temple. I was hoping for more detail, but the ideas were great either way. And I agree, we need an Indy-like ride ASAP!
Jasonflz’s Diamond Caverns are really nice. This is just the thing Frontierland needs for its kinetics and stuff Also, I like shiny things…
Jasonflz’s Enchanted Forest Exploration seems good, but a little misleading. I was hoping for a peoplemover around the land, but I guess a darkride is okay, too.
Bamsk8er49’s Swingig in the Trees This is a great idea, it really works with the Adventureland theme!
Bamsk8er49’s Stitch Space Chase I’m not a big fan of this, but I guess it’s O.K… for another “bad stitch” ride…
Bamsk8er49’s Princess and the Frog A little bland (you can sooo do better!) but O.K.



--Redo Main Street Exposition hall with NEW walkthrough
Jasonflz Once again, nice but without enough inspiration. It’s too bad, because this has roots that can bloom!
Bamsk8er49 The ideas for “exposition” really come through here, but it’s not fantastic. I suppose you really can’t complain about a hidden nugget…


With that said… THE WINNER is…… Bamsk8er49. Both Disneyson and I thought that you had improved the most from throughout the season, and really took our comments to heart, and improved on our ideas. And welcome to the judging team for The Imagineer—Season 2.

See You All Next Season!


NOTE: I cant speak for Disneyson, but I can say for myself, that it was a hard decision. And I know I based my decision on who changed the most and came the most way. I hope to see you next season Jasonflz. J
 

Jasonflz

Well-Known Member
Congrats to Bam. :wave: I really think he did a good job, and I agree with the judges decision.

And yes, I definitely will be back for next season.
 

Disneyson 1

New Member
WOW. That was amazing. Uh, sorry Jasonflz, but you did really well! It really was hard, but Bam improved the most. Everyone did great, and I can't wait for next season (You're judging, right Bam?)

Bye for now!
 

Jasonflz

Well-Known Member
WOW. That was amazing. Uh, sorry Jasonflz, but you did really well! It really was hard, but Bam improved the most. Everyone did great, and I can't wait for next season (You're judging, right Bam?)

Bye for now!

:) Thanks. I really think he did a great job on improving from his earlier projects.
 
tyvm everyone!! im gonna be honest and say i thought Jason won because of the public voting and because he did a GREAT job on the project, honestly you rele did. and also for those who don't know, Paul Bunyan's is a restaurant in the show Phineas and ferb and is shown in the show. they pass it and a little jingle thats "paul bunyan's where the food is good, but not too good eh!" plays, its sort of those little things in the show that go unnoticed that i wanted to incorporate, and so is dannys guitar shop and bobby's hair salon. those r from an episode where they're bringing a band back together nd those r their professions after the band broke up. all in all, it was a great thing and i can't wait for season 2 to start up, I'M JUDGING! haha tyvm everyone
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom