Fractal514
Well-Known Member
And here I thought we were pretty great... Turns out we stink 
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
The Imagineer 2--R1, Project 3
- Thread starter MaterA113
- Start date
Chrononymous
Well-Known Member
Thank You Judges! It's awesome to get feedback!!!
Disneyson 1
New Member
I was SO dissapointed with both of these projects... they could have had potential, yet... well, they were extremely lacking.
Goofy's Brainstormers
While far from perfect, you were fine in terms of the project. The dialogue was... well, predictable and somewhat boring. Some things were just kinda thrown in there (Kid ringing a bell? When did he get that???), and some were just a little too scary (the "masked native"). Overall, though, the concept was good. And last season I said NO MORE SHRUNKEN NED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Does anyone read these comments?!? *grr...*
Chip 'n' Dale's Imagineering Rangers
Well, it started with a great idea... but just collapsed into itself for several reasons... One, the effects were nearly impossible to pull off in the way you wanted to. I mean, really! It's a freaking train; How do you expect the Alien to pounce onto the WHOLE train? Two, the ideas were everywhere! Is the narrator a good guy with the classic "Railroad" voice or a "Ghost Host" character. I just couldn't tell, because he seemed nice enough until he started going "hahahahah"... what does that mean??? And also, why is BUZZ LIGHTYEAR, of all characters, fighting THE (very child unfriendly) ALIEN??? It just doesn't make sense!!! Third, the reliance on real people was just too great. This ride is VERY impossible and doesn't mean anything; not a story, not a "spectacle", just... weird. And not very good.
Goofy's Brainstormers
While far from perfect, you were fine in terms of the project. The dialogue was... well, predictable and somewhat boring. Some things were just kinda thrown in there (Kid ringing a bell? When did he get that???), and some were just a little too scary (the "masked native"). Overall, though, the concept was good. And last season I said NO MORE SHRUNKEN NED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Does anyone read these comments?!? *grr...*
Chip 'n' Dale's Imagineering Rangers
Well, it started with a great idea... but just collapsed into itself for several reasons... One, the effects were nearly impossible to pull off in the way you wanted to. I mean, really! It's a freaking train; How do you expect the Alien to pounce onto the WHOLE train? Two, the ideas were everywhere! Is the narrator a good guy with the classic "Railroad" voice or a "Ghost Host" character. I just couldn't tell, because he seemed nice enough until he started going "hahahahah"... what does that mean??? And also, why is BUZZ LIGHTYEAR, of all characters, fighting THE (very child unfriendly) ALIEN??? It just doesn't make sense!!! Third, the reliance on real people was just too great. This ride is VERY impossible and doesn't mean anything; not a story, not a "spectacle", just... weird. And not very good.
Fractal514
Well-Known Member
I'm not sure if you're joking or not, but I wasn't around for last season, and would appreciate if you'd remind us of anything pertinent to the projects that you might have said last season, lol...
Chrononymous
Well-Known Member
I appreciate these judge comments a lot! It gives me an idea of what you are all looking for, in terms of projects.
I wasn't around for last season either...
and in my defence...I had never heard the term Shrunken Ned before it was suggested in our thread! And I thought...cool! What a great Halloween role for the Chief to play! Ha ha...
er...next time I guess I have to do more research...
I wasn't around for last season either...
and in my defence...I had never heard the term Shrunken Ned before it was suggested in our thread! And I thought...cool! What a great Halloween role for the Chief to play! Ha ha...
er...next time I guess I have to do more research...
Disneyson 1
New Member
Nah, it's fine. Just... I'm a little sick of Ned...