Matt_Black
Well-Known Member
For me, the issue with the prequels was not that it wasn't like the original trilogy, but that for the most part it just didn't feel like Star Wars. JJ did an awesome job with making this movie feel like the originals. From the look of the worlds and the characters to the visual effects and the designs all felt like authentic Star Wars to me. I think people just wish they had gone out on the ledge a bit more with the story.
Well, they pointed out on Cracked.com that the original trilogy's tone was all over the place. Star Wars was straight up homage to Flash Gordon, Buck Rogers, and other pulp magazine and serial film fare. Empire was dark and broody. Return was essentially one big toy commercial. So yeah, it's hard to make the prequels feel like the original trilogy, especially when Lucas cut out so many of the people actually responsible for those films being great in the first place.