I can't fully judge this update to the Great Movie Ride until I can ride it again, but based on the photos and videos, it doesn't look too bad. The best part about the whole thing is that the lighting, audio and sounds, and animatronics have been spruced up. The ride looks better, in terms of maintenance, than it has for the past few years.
I'm not a fan of the onboard audio. It seems awkward in some parts and it's hard to hear some in areas of the ride. I much prefer the Cast Member host speaking the whole time. However, it could have been much worse. I would have been devastated if they cut out the host speaking entirely or removed the interaction sequences with the bandit/gangster.
The new preshow is awesome! I'm really going to miss the old trailers, though. Going into the old movie house setting and watching the original trailers for classic movies like Casablanca and Raiders of the Lost Ark was always a treasured experience for me. With that being said, the new preshow looks like it has been done with a lot of care. At 45 minutes long, no one will have to worry about seeing the same things twice while in line! The back story of each genre and clips from the films featured in ride is a great addition to the Great Movie Ride. I hope it will inspire more people to seek out these classic movies to watch them. I've always been a fan of classic movies since I was a child, but the Great Movie Ride was my introduction to several great classics like Singing the Rain and Footlight Parade. Because of the Great Movie Ride, I've now become a HUGE fan of James Cagney.
As for the new finale montage, I can't say I like it. I'm glad they kept many of the movies and sequences from the original montage. Nostalgia aside, the original montage had a much better flow and better transitions between the films. For example, after the "wait a minute, you ain't heard nothin' yet!" line from The Jazz Singer, I always expect the screen to broaden and the Show Boat riverboat to appear. The new montage is just bizarre in how it cuts sometimes. The music was much grander and more memorable in the original montage. I do like how they added Steamboat Willie, Poltergeist, and Some Like it Hot. However, they removed a lot more films than they added to the montage. And most the movies they added are not classic at all. They removed movies from the montage like Fantasia, The Absent Minded Professor, Who Framed Roger Rabbit, and True Grit, but added movies like Tangled, Frozen, and Guardians of the Galaxy. Really?!
Overall, this update to the Great Movie Ride looks like it has more cons than pros. However, I was expecting it to be worse. At least this often overlooked and underrated attraction is getting some attention.