While I agree with the “too big for their britches” part, I definitely do not want Disney to just stick to “singing princess“ films. That path will lead to stagnation. Zootopia and The Lion King were two of the biggest hits, financially and critically, in Disney’s history. The problem with Strange World isn’t genre, it’s in whatever’s going on at the studio that allowed a good idea like Strange World to proceed through production into final release without addressing its many script issues. What’s going on? The film needed someone to come in and fix the writing, and—with millions upon millions of dollars at stake—that didn’t happen.
When I, off the top of my head, compare Strange World to Puss in Boots: TLW, this is the first thing that comes to mind:
Puss in Boots TLW: Fresh, sharp, spontaneous
Strange World: Overworked, overthought
I’m sure a TON of story meetings and rewrites went into PIBTLW, but the film still feels spontaneous and surprising.
Strange World FEELS like a film that was written and approved by a committee of compromise.
That’s what Disney Animation has to fix.