I'm pretty sure I fall mid-way between the 1 and 4. Having gone opening day, my first impressions of it were great, but once my initial excitement wore off, I was able to analyze the land a bit more level-headed.
One example of this was the Falcon. Entering the cockpit and just being there was by and large the best part of the ride. Had it been any other IP or ship, the ride would've just been meh honestly. The thing about that is that repeat rides will not have the shock and awe of getting to sit in the Millenium Falcon, which boils it down to just being an okay simulator.
To be fair, I was only an engineer, so my opinions could change if in another position but as an avid gamer, the mission was rather dull and the fact that we had to actively rely on the suburban mother in the gunner seat in front of me who was wayyy more focused on recording her children and husband experiencing the ride than experiencing it herself was irksome.