Oh trust me I agree with you. The last few days I had been on the phone with Disney working out the details of me changing reservations from Yacht Club to Beach Club because of their allowing dogs. I love animals, but I think this is a terrible idea. If Disney wants to make more money, start After Hours for Animal Kingdom and charge $120 for a 3 hour ticket. If it helps beat the mob scene for Flight of Passage, it's worth it to me.
As far as the dogs, they say and people say that dog rooms have their own wing but there's not by themselves in a wing. Guests are there as well. I don't see how Disney is going to enforce this "well-behaved dog policy". Come on. Do you really think people are going to go to MK for a day, and then leave because they got a phone call saying their dog was barking? People wouldn't answer their phones.
I'm just totally against the dog idea, and I love dogs myself. It doesn't matter how well trained they are, they are in a strange hotel with people around they don't know as well as other dogs around, dogs are going to miss their owners being locked in a hotel room for 7 hours.
Plus housekeeping can't go in those rooms and clean every day. Like I shudder at the idea of what a room looks like after a 7 day trip with a dog in it. Just saying.