News Reflections of Earth confirmed to be replaced by Harmonious

[Clamman73]

Is there survey bias built into Disney surveys by putting choices in a particular order that may favor their hopeful result?

 

[James Alucobond]

Is there survey bias built into Disney surveys by putting choices in a particular order that may favor their hopeful result?
View attachment 619671

No, unless it pre-selects the "better" radio or runs counter to the order or logic used in other similar questions (e.g. question 5 starts with "better", but question 6 starts with "worse").

 

[brb1006]

Wow, what the heck is going on in this thread?

 

[MrPromey]

I’m already in line and they don’t release until April. Will live-stream.

How far back are you?

 

[vikescaper]

How do I get one of these fancy surveys people speak of? Been three times and haven't seen one

I used to get the surveys all the time but I rarely get them now.

 

[TikibirdLand]

I used to get the surveys all the time but I rarely get them now.

You must be answering them wrong!

 

[123mart123]

@lentesta said:
“That said, if people look at the Harmonious barges and decide they're ugly and then skip the show, that's a problem that's not going to show up in the survey results.”

the Harmonious barges make me like Disney less…let alone EPCOT.

 

[123mart123]

I'm sure in the company they're wondering why they spent (and are spending) so much on a new show when the return is looking even if not worse then a "simple" show like EF. Regardless of my feelings of the show, I'd expect better ratings simply because it's new.

Not if its “NEW” but its a mediocre show that is only mediocre from a few premium viewing spots and sub-mediocre from everywhere else.

 

[vikescaper]

You must be answering them wrong!

I think I have been too critical with my answers. Thankfully, my sister still gets them so she sends them to me to fill out!

 

[JeffH]

"Worse"? This implies that Illuminations was bad, perhaps "not as good as" would be more appropriate. I don't know what "IllumiNations 25" was but when IllumiNations debuted at the Millennium (2000) it was the best show ever, brought tears to my eyes with happy emotion and the only change I ever noticed in that show was that some of the fireworks were nerfed down and towards the end, the lagoon effects went away.
MY problem with the new show is that when you consider all the hardware in the water (and the eyesore it creates) that the show should be much better. Here they have new HD viewscreens and they waste them showing crappy puppet stick figure depictions of our beloved animated characters...why nerf down the animation????? Is it supposed to be cute??? I would think that they would use the screens to show our beloved animations then sweep over to their real-life depiction remakes. Since it is a 50-year show it maybe should have represented the changes (good and bad) at Disney World?

 

[MisterPenguin]

Is there survey bias built into Disney surveys by putting choices in a particular order that may favor their hopeful result?
View attachment 619671

I would've thought with how surveys are cooked, the only two answers would be:

​

o Better​

o Much Better​

 

[fgmnt]

I half haphazardly watched Harmonious for the first time a few weeks ago. While admittedly not in a great view for prime judgment... I listened to the RoE score on the way home.

At the end of the day, the company saw fit to spend unholy sums of money on a show that is ultimately less impactful than its 20 year old predecessor. A successor to Reflections of Earth was overdue; it was a 20 year old production with even older direct predecessors. What we were given in Harmonious was a show conceived, built, and scored by people who have quite obviously never been to EPCOT Center as members of the public, or even cast members on some free time. It's fine, I guess. At best. If debut satisfaction scores of Harmonious among the alcohol-buying crowd are lower than the twilight of RoE, that has to be incredibly dire, no?

The vibe I get from Martin is that a rework is inevitable. I doubt we will rid ourselves of the tacos so soon, but I almost feel like we should /expect/ a rewrite of the show to be announced by Labor Day.

 

[UNCgolf]

I would've thought with how surveys are cooked, the only two answers would be:

​

o Better​

o Much Better​

When compared to Reflections of Earth, is Harmonious...

• a more fulfilling experience
• a less boring experience
• a masterpiece
• a more Disney and more timeless show
• a crowning example of show design
• all of the above

 

[Vegas Disney Fan]

I don’t know that I could answer this question, I find the harmonious show much better but the daytime barges are a massive eyesore.

If they offered to scrap Harmonious and bring back Illuminations tomorrow, solely based on my answer, I don’t know what I’d choose.

Happily ever after on the other hand would be back tomorrow without hesitation.

 

[Branman]

It's "both/and" not "either/or."

Financial and operational data can already tell them things like "TS F&B revenue is down X% versus 2019" or "Epcot has fallen from 40% share of park-hopping guests to 30%," and then they use guest surveys to tease out the why.

I really wish we knew the F&B numbers. The big question is: are they selling more tacos than in 2019?

 

[Vinnie Mac]

They ask questions they know the answer to and select the participants to get the statistics they want. So, I agree; it's not a big deal. Move along...

You really think for one second that Disney needs your approval to do what they want? You really think one of the biggest companies on the planet need to rig a poll to do whatever they want with their money...?

 

[Vinnie Mac]

I don’t know that I could answer this question, I find the harmonious show much better but the daytime barges are a massive eyesore.

If they offered to scrap Harmonious and bring back Illuminations tomorrow, solely based on my answer, I don’t know what I’d choose.

Happily ever after on the other hand would be back tomorrow without hesitation.

The best nighttime show lineup possible right now imho would be:

MK: Happily Ever After
Epcot: HarmonioUS
DHS: Fantasmic and Star Wars (though I am still satisfied with a Fantasmic solo run)
AK: New nighttime show with story but more exciting than that river whatever show



In a perfect world, we could have both Wishes and HEA running at the same time as well as ROE and HarmonioUS running at the same time. But this isn't a perfect world, so we'll work with what we got.

 

[ImperfectPixie]

You really think for one second that Disney needs your approval to do what they want? You really think one of the biggest companies on the planet need to rig a poll to do whatever they want with their money...?

Surveys that provide desired responses give executives ammunition to "prove" that they made a correct decision to higher-ups.

 

[Vinnie Mac]

Surveys that provide desired responses give executives ammunition to "prove" that they made a correct decision to higher-ups.

Okay, so I'll throw this question at you. Exactly what narrative do you think is being pushed?

 

[Vinnie Mac]

Nope, purely a hypothetical situation to represent that even IF I had that kind of power I couldn’t decide.

Right, but my point is that Disney doesn't need to rig a poll to do something. Disney and every theme park company can do whatever they please in essence.