Please Please Please do not use food to reward/punish a child (long again, sorry)

EmOhYouEssE

New Member
Original Poster
Possible reasons for hoarding/hiding food

I just got off of the phone with my best friend. Her son is going through a divorce, so his wife recently moved out. Her and her daughter decided to go help him clean the house.

Background: the soon to be Ex is a very sweet girl. She really is. But she also had some "quirks" when it came to food. For instance, if we were all camping and someone was snacking on something, she always asked if she could have some, regardless of what it was. When going out to eat, she would always order the most expensive thing, eat half, then order dessert and eat a bite and discard the rest. There were other little things over the last few years, but we all blew it off as one of her quirks. She seemed to feel a sense of accomplishment when obtaining food, especially if it was someone else's food (for instance, everyone was eating pizza rolls as a snack one day and my friend's 4 year old niece was finished with hers and wanted more. The soon to be ex still had some, and proceeded to shove all of hers that were left on her plate in her mouth at once and laugh at the child; although there were more that could be made).

Well when my friend and her daughter were helping clean the house, apparently there was food hidden all over the house in drawers and such. Oatmeal cookies under a pile of bills here, some ring dings under something there. Well the son was cleaning a drawer of old clothes out, and he found a half eaten cake still in the pyrex dish hidden under some of his old clothes.

To me, this is the type of behavior an alcoholic displays when hiding booze. She wasn't an extremely large girl or anything, but she definitely had some food issues.

The only thing we could come up with is that food was used as some sort of punishment/reward system in her home growing up. Her parents are very controlling, and I don't see it being out of their scope of ways to influence her behavior. Especially after thinking back about all of the "quirks" she had regarding food over the years.

Anyone else have experience with this type of behavior regarding food and what could be the cause of it?

Em
 

DisneyGigi

Well-Known Member
Wow, that makes me wonder what she went through as a child. It may be that she did not have enough and stockpiles as a precaution as a result. I read an article once about a person that did this. Either that or maybe an adult made them feel guilty about eating or as you said used it as a reward/punishment.
Either way- very sad. You never know what has went on in someone's life that affects them as adults. :(
 

DormaNesbit

Member
Hi Em...another stand point to think about is maybe she is bolemic (sorry if spelled wrong). When in a panic about anything she may feel the need to binge and then purge. Since the panic can come at anytime, the need to have food hidden everywhere. Just an observation.

Mari
 

Nemo14

Well-Known Member
I think to blame this as the result of rewarding/punishing with food is pretty over-simplifying. Clearly this woamn has/had major issues, and although food may have been her way of dealing with things, the roots of her problems are certainly much deeper than we can surmise on a message board. JMHO
 

maggiegrace1

Well-Known Member
I think there is more to it..way more then the rewarding of food thing..
I think basically almost every parent does that with a child..

If you do this then you can have ice cream

Or eat all your dinner then you can have dessert..

I think there is something else there..JMO!
 

EmOhYouEssE

New Member
Original Poster
Thanks for the other avenues of thought Dorma and Disneyshe! Both of those options are definite posibilities as to her behavior; although I'm thinking we would have noticed the binge/purge behavior, escpecially when camping in remote places with no bathrooms. It's not out of the question though. Also, the father is very very controlling of both the mother and her, so, it is possible that he limited what was spent on food in the house although they lived quite comfortably.

And Nemo: Yes I realize it's deep rooted causes and I probably should have worded my title "possible reasons for food hoarding", so my apologies on that. I was just very concerned for this girl and my friend's son, as he still very much cares for her; their marriage just didn't work out as hoped. Any avenues of thought on the process of this behavior only helps him try to find ways to help her, that was the intention of my initial post. It wasn't to try to psychoanalyze this poor girl.

It's obvious she has issues, and all possible reasons that could be suggested to the son as to the reasons would help in communicating with her as friends (in my opinion).

Em
 

Laura

22
Premium Member
I think to blame this as the result of rewarding/punishing with food is pretty over-simplifying. Clearly this woamn has/had major issues, and although food may have been her way of dealing with things, the roots of her problems are certainly much deeper than we can surmise on a message board. JMHO

Totally agree. It's kind of silly to say that anyone who uses food as a reward will ruin their child. You really have no idea WHY this girl hides food and only a psychologist could get to the root of that.

My kids always get ice cream sundaes or a trip to McDonalds as a reward for good behavior.
 

DisneyGigi

Well-Known Member
^ I agree with above statements. I did not mean as in desserts or treats but the story that I read was about withholding meals/dinners on a regular basis. It really broke my heart. :(
 

EmOhYouEssE

New Member
Original Poster
Totally agree. It's kind of silly to say that anyone who uses food as a reward will ruin their child. You really have no idea WHY this girl hides food and only a psychologist could get to the root of that.

My kids always get ice cream sundaes or a trip to McDonalds as a reward for good behavior.

I've already stated that I should have worded the title differently. Please feel free to crucify me for it over and over again rather than give constructive ideas :shrug:.

EM
 

DznyGrlSD

Well-Known Member
In the Parks
Yes
I was raised in a 'clean your plate' family. We weren't necessarily rewarded with food but we weren't denied it either...There's a reason I ballooned to 319 pounds before deciding to do something about it...

...down 70 pounds and PROUD of it
 

Montyboy

New Member
Thanks for the other avenues of thought Dorma and Disneyshe! Both of those options are definite posibilities as to her behavior; although I'm thinking we would have noticed the binge/purge behavior, escpecially when camping in remote places with no bathrooms. It's not out of the question though. Also, the father is very very controlling of both the mother and her, so, it is possible that he limited what was spent on food in the house although they lived quite comfortably.

And Nemo: Yes I realize it's deep rooted causes and I probably should have worded my title "possible reasons for food hoarding", so my apologies on that. I was just very concerned for this girl and my friend's son, as he still very much cares for her; their marriage just didn't work out as hoped. Any avenues of thought on the process of this behavior only helps him try to find ways to help her, that was the intention of my initial post. It wasn't to try to psychoanalyze this poor girl.

It's obvious she has issues, and all possible reasons that could be suggested to the son as to the reasons would help in communicating with her as friends (in my opinion).

Em
It sure sounds that way, but I guess you are trying to help.
You could ask her. She might want to get it off her chest.

Nce job Fallen Angel.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom