No, they aren't. I shouldn't have to walk ten minutes to get to any of the restaurants, the pool, the gift shop, the front desk, the main lobby.
Nobody is forcing you to stay at those resorts. Do research or ask questions. The only people who complain about walking 10 minutes are the people who did not do the proper research beforehand, and did not know what they were getting into.
What that means is the properties are too spread out. The point is they shouldn't be as spread out as they are. That's what makes them inconvenient.
Again, Moderates and Values typically have more rooms than deluxe. And more rooms likely equates to more land, and more walking. Part of the Deluxe package is being close to restaurants, the lobby, transportation, etc. If walking is truly that much of an inconvenience, then take a bus, or don't stay at the large resorts.
While that may be true, they certainly don't have to spread out to encompass the size of DHS. Can you imagine being in Pixar Place and having to walk to ToT in order to find a restaurant to eat? That cerainly isn't convenient.
To find a restaurant? The one or two food options at the moderate or value resorts are not the only dining locations on WDW property. And on a week long vacation, how many times are you really going to use the one sit-down restaurant the mod or value resort offers (if it even has one)? If it is such an inconvenience walking 10 minutes to eat, people must go crazy having to walk 20 minutes from the Epcot entrance gate all the way to countries in World Showcase.
Disney charges extra for that. Isn't that their "Preferred Room" locations?
Nope, not true. Casitas, Ranchos, and Cabanas are all the same rate. They don't 100% guarantee your room when you make a request, but we have never had an issue with asking for Casitas, which is close to the lobby of Coronado Springs.
And in no way is taking a bus within the hotel in order to grab a bite to eat or visit the gift shop convenient. I don't know how anyone can logically argue that!
Again, nobody is forcing you to stay at these resorts. If you do research, you will find that not all resorts are like this. And even within the resorts that are, there are rooms you can request, or just get by chance, that are closer to the lobby, if that is so important.