The original point started in another thread. Some people, myself included, said her accent and voice didn’t match well with the other pirates and seems random in comparison.
I’m sure we can all agree that pirates came from everywhere. However the main gist of the argument was that Redd sticks out like a sore thumb in the attraction because of her new, cowgirl (thanks,
@mickEblu) voice and her Irish accent, which doesn’t match the sounds and accents of the other figures.
I probably wouldn’t mind the accent so much of the tone of voice and matched more with the other figures.