I've been thinking about Pixar Pier today, and have a few musings...
I must say, I had no idea that Paradise Pier had so many diehard fans that are upset at this news!
Paradise Pier was rethemed in 2010-11 to add a whole bunch of "Disney" characters, mostly just slapped onto the side of existing rides from 2001. Along with the reskin of existing structures with far nicer Victorian themed overlays, it was a nice freshening of what was arguably the weakest and cheapest looking section of DCA.
Paradise Pier went from this Paul Pressler stucco masterpiece...
To this properly budgeted and Imagineered environment....
Pixar Pier appears to be a similar project, replacing the Disney characters slapped on things with Pixar characters. Midway Mania is already there as an anchor attraction themed to Pixar, but there are still some sections of the Pier that haven't been upgraded fully from their 2001 cheap Paul Pressler aesthetic - King Triton's Carousel, Sideshow Shirts, Fun Wheel queue, all of California Screamin'.
Hopefully the Pixar Pier project will address those four remaining areas, and it's apparent the Sideshow Shirts building and Fun Wheel queue get plussed up from the one piece of official artwork released.
And it looks like they are using the work already done at Tokyo DisneySea for their Midway Mania mini-land as inspiration; an early 1900's trolley amusement park. (The trolley companies built these to encourage weekend use of their rail lines.)
So far, so good for me.
But the big question is what becomes of all the Disney characters that were pushed into the Pier back in 2010?
There's still that Hollywood Backlot expansion out into the East Esplanade bus loading zones that is coming. And there's a new Mickey dark ride going into DHS, which was rumored to be under consideration for DCA's Hollywood area. The Hollywood expansion could be themed to classic Disney characters, eliminating Monsters Inc. And the Marvel expansion is rumored by Miceage to include A Bug's Land, eliminating another Pixar franchise.
This could mean that since Pixar will be eliminated from the rest of DCA, except for Cars Land obviously, WDI is giving the Pier over to Pixar while they remake big chunks of the rest of the park into properly Imagineered homes for Disney and Marvel characters.
Looking at the long game here of 5 to 7 years from now, that could very well be the method behind the madness of Pixar Pier for 2018. Judging from how insanely happy and hyper John Lasseter was when he announced this at D23,
which even caused him to slur his words and act like a fool which was obviously not related to alcohol use whatsoever , Pixar Pier is the bone WDI and Burbank throw the Pixar team to keep them playing along as they remove Pixar from the rest of DCA