I'd put Cutler in the "above average" group. He can make plays, but he's not going to lead a team year in and year out. The only 4 I would put in the "elite" group are Rodgers, Brady, Manning, and Brees. The QB position has gotten so crucial to a team's success that average, or slightly above average, QB are getting paid like the elite ones. If a team can find a way to devalue the QB position, then they will have tremendous success in this league. Unfortunately, with the rules and everything, I don't think there is a long-term solution to devaluing the QB.