The issue is when it becomes a necessity. Just look at the number of people on this board who have said at one time or another how if they don't get a FP for an attraction then they simply skip that attraction. What happens when it gets to the point that you HAVE to make these kinds of reservations or the trip will be miserable? Not dissimilar to dining, where "standby" is pretty much impossible.
And that's fine if you want to microplan your day...but what happens when everyone has to do that in order to enjoy their day? Your decision, which is above and beyond what any normal vactioner whould decide, is now adversely affecting my trip. (Of course, this is worst case scenario).
And for the record, I never said I don't use FP. In fact I use it all the time. I rarely make ADRs (and when I do it is day of).
This is what I am afraid of, being sucked into the system because its either use Fastpass+ or stand in long standby lines.
I would be Ok with reserving maybe one or two rides a day, but I don't want to be locked into having to plan 8-10 attractions and effectively scheduling my entire day.
I have little kids, and its a known fact that parents with kids are a main WDW demographic. I know how difficult it is to plan an entire day at Disney and have everything go according to plan, because I've tried and failed miserably. My two year old is a pretty good theme park tourer, but still I've had him fall asleep in the stroller hours before his typical nap time, get hungry much earlier than I planned for lunch, decided that he doesn't want to ride a ride he previously loved, and ask to ride a ride multiple times that I wasn't planning on riding at all (the carousel).
I suppose I could be mean mom, wake him up from sleeping, forcing him to go hungry, force him on rides he doesn't like and make him skip things he's interested in, all for the sake of the schedule, but that doesn't seem like much fun.
I just don't want to be stuck in this type of scenario, i.e. ride according to your pre-planned schedule or don't ride at all. I know there is standby, but there is no way I'm getting in a line that is more than 15 minutes long with a toddler. I know his limitations and I don't want to be the mom of the child that is running amok through the chain partitions. You all don't want me to be that mom! :ROFLOL:
Please, Disney, don't make this too hard on parents and kids, you don't want to loose our business!