So, I watched this without seeing the Frozen or last Star Wars show previously...
One.. the star destroyer sequence is awesome...
The projections in the very beginning of the show are pretty weak... but go through more ups than downs as the show progresses
The sequencing leading up to the finale is pretty good, and the moment they pop to the lightsaber spot light is awesome
But the bads?
The show really seems to lack direction through the sequences. They just seem all over the place without any real pacing and control of the tempo to build to. I mean we get climax sequences all mixed in in various places.. maybe at one point we feel we get a villians sequence but again it seems to blur in and out. The show really seems to lack cohesion in this sense of having a structure to control the progression and tempo you want to guide the audience through.
The pyro seems ok, but nothing to write home about in terms of special, just adds to the show.
The show being pretty much entirely the GMR plaza area and not much else... in the era of paid seating areas, clearly its going to be messy in terms of getting comfortable viewing areas due to the contention and limited space available.
Overall I thought it was a show I really liked... much more so than any of the other shows I've seen recently. I mean I wasn't looking for the fast forward button after 3-4 minutes like most of Disney's shows of late. Minus the park ops things... I thought the show looked like a nice addition.
Then I went back and watched
@wdwmagic's videos on Frozen and the prior star wars show. I can totally understand other people's complaints about the Pyro and viewing. The prior shows were very much Fireworks shows on the scale of Wishes! and were pretty damn good! Fireworks that would make any Disney park proud (and me upset I missed them on our last trip due to their late announcement of their start date). This new show is certainly not even in the same zip code as those shows when it comes to a Fireworks show vs a 'castle show' level.
Spectacle.. is a Disney fireworks show... Galactic Spectacular is a great 'castle show'.
The real kick in the gut is how Disney goes through the efforts to create this new launch site... and the fireworks presentation we get as a result of these changes is a fraction of what we used to get??? That is the most gut wrenching part of all of this IMO. I know people were talking about fallout in the past shows, but tweak, not gut the thing :/
Screw TSL needing to be open, etc... run that caliber of show at park closing and people won't be upset over some parts of the park closing 30mins early, etc.