Yes, the eBay part sets off a lot of alarm bells to me, as well. If someone has those kinds of APs and travels across multiple states a half dozen times a year, they are part of the "Disney community" in some way online, and listing it on an auction site wouldn't be the first way I would think one would get rid of them if that's all they wanted. The eBay details are sketchy - was it Buy It Now where they listed a price? They could have done that - but it sounds like it was an actual "whomever pays the most" auction.
If the tickets in the incident I
mentioned above hadn't been refunded in our case and I was truly stuck with them, my plan was just to come here and look at the trip boards and find someone who was going to just give them to. I just wouldn't have touched reselling them with a ten-foot pole, not out of fear of Disney but mostly because they are registered to your account, and you have to change the name on your own/add someone to your party/mess with that stuff, and just didn't want the responsibility of taking money for it if it didn't work.
Agreed x10.
Or even if they weren't, they are at least aware of the level of service Disney provides and would have at least attempted to get them refunded. It doesn't make sense - they knew they were not refundable, so didn't bother to try, but also didn't know they weren't transferable? Seems like if all they wanted was to break even, they would have at least
tried to contact Disney.
As I said above, all it took was one quick phone call for me, I didn't have to escalate or speak with a supervisor or anything. I *think* the lovely girl I talked to may have put me on hold for like 10 seconds at one point, perhaps to get approval (my brain was so fried at the time from so many phone calls in general with what I was dealing with, that I can't totally remember), but I do know I was on the phone for less than 5 minutes and had the refund in my account like a day or two later.
I just have a very hard time believing this story, it seems much more likely to me that they probably were sick and couldn't go, but instead of just trying to get a fair refund, they decided to try to make a few bucks off of it.